V'

f

i

I

V

PROCEEDINGS

of

The Numismatic and Antiquarian Society

of Philadelphia

FOR THE YEARS 1936 TO 1945 INCLUSIVE

VOL. 33

FOUNDED DECEMBER 28, 1857

PHILADELPHIA PUBLISHED BY THE SOCIETY 1946

. J.

. *

I

I

t

s

I

CONTEXTS

PAGE

Note on the Founding of The Numismatic and Antiquarian Society.... 5

Acknowledgments 8

Officers and Committees for the Years 1937-1945 9

Resident Members 18

Necrology 20

Meetings Held and Papers Given During the Years 1936-1945 21

Cabinet 26

Bequests 27

The Maxwell Sommerville Bequest 27

The Charles J. Cohen Publication Fund 27

J. Bertram Lippincott 29

Henry Paul Busch 30

Early Shipbuilding in Philadelphia, By Charles L. Chandler 31

John Franklin. By Julian P. Boyd 35

Colonial Frankford, By Horace W. Castor 50

Hemlocks, By Charles F. Jenkins 77

Chinese Procelain, By Lawrence J. Morris 82

The Work of the Oriental Institute in the Near East,

By Dr. John A. Wilson 100

Some Phases of the American Revolution, By Dr. Henry Pleasants, Jr.. 103

Living Souvenirs of Wm. Penn’s Day, By Dr. Edward H. Wildman 114

The Background and Antecedents of the Wistar Institute of Anatomy

and Biology, By Jansen Haines 124

Pennsbury — William Penn’s Manor and Its Restoration,

By Henry Paul Busch 131

The Story of the “Select School”, By Dr. Harris G. Haviland 138

Stephen Girard and Girard College, By Dr. Merle M. Odgers 143

The First Theatres of Philadelphia, By Thomas Ridgway 151

The Use of Gold in Currency, By Frank Lynwood Garrison 164

Franklin Looks at ’42, By John A. Stevenson 176

Some Philadelphia Houses, By Horace Mather Lippincott 184

French Spoliation Claims, By J. Henry Scattergood 203

Earliest Philadelphia Silversmiths, By LawTence J. Morris 231

Old Wonders in a New World, By William J. Phillips 236

Coins, By Alfred D. Norris 245

A Pine Street Church and Frankford Gunpowder in Colonial Days.

By Horace W. Castor 247

Denarii of the Twelve Caesars, By Richard T. Hoober 265

What Are Prints? By Carl Zigrosser 274

The First Munitions Smuggler of the Revolution,

By Dr. Henry Pleasants. Jr. 277 The Navajo Indian, By Chester E. Paris 295

>

'> i’%' ( ■:* '

4

V

. <

«

K»

. ♦ # "

w

4

'

4

t

% ■, .

f-.

1^.

\

♦

0

•is!

THE NUMISMATIC AND ANTIQUARIAN SOCIETY OF PHILADELPHIA

Hy Howard Longstreth

The preface to \TIume 1 of the Proceedings of the Numis- matic Society of Philadelphia records the fact that ‘‘on January 1. 1858 eight gentlemen, all citizens of Philadelphia, met and formed a society to encourage and promote Numismatic Science.” ( In December 1857 several of these gentlemen had met and dis- cussed the question of forming a Numismatic Society.) In those days an Act of Assembly was necessary for the incorjx)ration of an organization. On February 19, 1858 Governor Packer affixed his signature to a bill which brought the Numismatic Society of Philadelphia into being. This was the first society of its kind to be formed in the United States. During the Civil War period interest in coins abated to such an extent that many Numismatic Societies, ours included, branched out into antiquarian fields. On February 23, 1865, Governor Curtin signed a bill which changed our name to The Numismatic and Antiquarian .Society of Phila- delphia.

The Society has grown slowly through the years, until now it consists of about seventy-five members. We meet six times a year in the homes or clubs of the members, and at each meeting a paper is read. Most of the places of historic interest in and near Philadelphia have been visited. In order to show the wide range of subjects considered by the Society, the following list was taken at random from the last copy of the Proceedings: “Sheffield Plate;” “Symbolism of the American Flag;” “Some Old Masters of Painting ;” “Exhibitions of Coins by Members ;” “The Koran ;” “Pennsylvania Flintlocks;” “The Temploes of Baalbec ;” “The Coinage of the Greeks ;” “Early Shipbuilding in Philadelphia ;” “Mints and Coinage of the United States.” The last paper was read by Mr. Alfred D. Norris, our Associate Curator.

The collections of the Society are housed in Memorial Hall in Fairmount Park and consist of nearly eleven thousand coins and medals, over five hundred pieces of paper money, and twenty- three hundred pieces of emergency (j)aper) money’ issued in Europe during and after the World War. The Society has struck four medals, the Mickley, the Price, the Brinton, and the Dana, in honor of past presidents.

5

When I joined the Society, thirty-two years ago, there were three large collectors of coins in the membership and their names, doubtless, are familiar to you; Air. John Story Jenks, Mr. John T. Morris, and Mr. Clarence S. Bement. The Jenks and Bement collections were sold, but the valuable Morris collection went by bequest to the University of Pennsylvania Museum where it was placed on exhibition for several years. At present it is stored in boxes in the sub-basement of the Museum, and our Curator, Mr. Richard D. Norton, has tried to interest the Carnegie Foundation in financing the removal of this and the other Philadelphia col- lections to suitable quarters, and making a permanent exhibition with a Curator in charge.

Several other prominent numismatists have been members of the Society:

Dr. T. Louis Comparette came to Philadelphia from the Uni- versity of Alissouri in 1905 as Curator of the numismatic collec- tion at the Philadelphia Mint. Dr. Comparette was an accom- plished linguist, an archeologist, and an authority on minting. He was the author of a number of pamphlets on numismatic subjects. After his sudden death in July, 1922, the numismatic collection, together with the library at the Mint, was moved to Washington. At that time the Numismatic and Antiquarian Society made a vigorous protest agaiirst this action to the Secretary of the Treas- ury and to the Director of the Mint. Unfortunately, the collection, parts of which had been here for nearly a century, was trans- ferred.

Mr. John Reilly will be remembered as Treasurer and as a member of the Council of the American Numismatic Society. His collection in the hall of the Society in New York is now the ])rop- erty of the Society and is said to be the finest collection of Oriental coins in the world.

Mr. h'rederick 1). Langenheim, who died in 1937 at the age of ninety, was a well known numismatist and attended many of these conventions. Mr. Langenheim joined the Society in 1888 and as Curator of Numismatics took s])lendid care of our collec- tions for many years. He served as Vice-President and as IVesi- dent.

Mr. Harold Cillingham has lield several offices in our So- ciety and succeeded Mr. John Reilly as I'reasurer of the Ameri- can Numismatic Society. He sf)ld his s])lendid collection of four

6

thousand Orders of Chivalry and War Medals in its entirety in 19v^0. Mr, Gillingham has written several pamphlets.

Both of onr Curators. Mr. Norton and Mr. Norris, have fine collections and are adding to them constantly.

FOUNDERS OF THE SOCIETY

Arthur G. Coffin 1015 Clinton Street

Joseph J. Mickley ‘ 926 Market Street

William S. Vaux 1700 Arch Street

John Bohlen 1510 Walnut Street

Mark W. Colket, M.D 329 South Broad Street

J. Ledvard Hodge 139 South Fifth Street

Samuel H. Fulton 615 South Ninth Street

Montgomery L. Frederick. . 153 South Fourth Street Alfred B. Taylor Ninth and Walnut Streets

7

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The cuts of coins and paper money courtes}'^ of American Numismatic Association

Illustrations in “The Navajo Indian” hy Chester E. Faris, are photographs by Edgar Snow, Window Rock. Arizona. re])roduced from “Urgent Navajo Problems” by courtesy of Mrs. John J. Kirk, Chairman of the Department of Social Welfare. State of New Mexico.

1937

OFFICERS

President Emeritus FREDERICK D. LANGENHEIM

President

J. BERTRAM LIPPINCOTT

Vice-Presidents

HOWARD LONGSTRETH HARROLD E. GILLINGHAM

Recording Secretary

Corresponding Secretary

Treasurer

H istoriographer

Curator Emeritus of Numismatics

Curator of Numismatics

Curator of Antiquities

Librarian

J. STOGDELL STOKES RICHARD PETERS, JR.

HENRV PAUL BUSCH ARTHUR C. CARTY HENRY P. McTLHENNY LAWRENCE J. MORRIS FREDERICK D. LANGENHEIM RICHARD D. NORTON HARROLD E. GILLINGHAM ALFRED D. NORRIS

Committees

numismatics GARRETT L. REILLY ALFRED D. NORRIS J. HENRY SCATTERGOOD

GENEALOGY

S. W. WOODHOUSE, JR.

H. BARTOL BRAZIER JOSEPH G. LESTER

publication ARTHUR C. CARTY LAWRENCE J. MORRIS ARTHUR L. BYE

FINANCE

ROBERT C. LEA THOMAS EVANS CHARLES F. JENKINS

ANTIQUITIES

CALEB J. MILNE, JR.

F. LYNWOOD GARRISON WARREN MILNE

LIBRARY

EDWARD HOOPES HARROLD E. GILLINGHAM WALTER S. MeINNES

MEMBERSHIP

W. W. HEARNE BENJAMIN R. HOFFAIAN PERCIVAL E. FOERDERER

PROGRA M

HOWARD LONGSTRETH S. W. WOODHOUSE, JR. CLIFFORD LEWIS, JR.

9

1938

OFFICERS

President

J. BERTRAM LTPPINCOTT

Vice-Presidents

HOWARD LOXGSTRETH HARROLD E. GILLINGHAM

Recording Secretary

Corresponding Secretary

Treasurer

Historiographer

Curator of Nuinis7natics

Assistant Curator of N umisniatics

Curator of Antiquities

Librarian

J. STOGDELL STOKES RICHARD PETERS, JR.

HENRY PAUL BUSCH HENRY PAUL BUSCH HENRY P. McILHENNY LAWRENCE J. MORRIS RICHARD E. NORTON ALFRED D. NORRIS HARROLD E. GILLINGHAM CLIFFORD LEWIS, 3RD

Com mittees

NUMISMATICS

GARRETT L. REILLY ALFRED D. NORRIS J. HENRY SCATTERGOOD

GENEALOCIY

S. W. WOODHOUSE, JR.

H. BARTOL BRAZIER JOSEPH G. LESTER

PUIIUICATION

HORACE W. CASTOR LAWRENCE J. MORRIS JULIAN P. BOYD

FINANCE

THOMAS EVANS CHARLES E. JENKINS CLII<FORD LIAVTS, JR.

ANTIQUITIES

CALEB J. MILNE. JR.

F. LYNWOOD GARRISON WARREN MILNE

LIBRARY

EDWARD HOOPES HARROLD E. GILLINGHAM WALTER S. McINNES

M E M HERS H I P

BENJAMIN R. HOFFMAN PERCIVAL E. FOERDEREI HERBERT CASEY

PROIiRA M

HOWARD LONG S T R 1 VP 1 1 S. W. WOODHOUSE. JR.

grevillp: haslam

10

1939

OFFICERS

President

J. BFRTRAM LIPPINCOTT

Vice-Presidents

HOWARD LONGSTRETPI RICHARD PETPZRS, JR.

• J. STOGDELL STOKES LAWRENCE J. MORRIS

Recording Secretary HENRY PAUL BUSCH

Corresponding Secretary HENRY PAUL BUSCH

Treasurer BENJAMIN R. HOEEMAN

Historiographer GARRETT L. REILLY

Curator of Niunisinatics RICHARD D. NORTON

Assistant Curator of Numismatics ALERED D. NORRIS

Curator of Antiquities E. LYNWOOD GARRISON

Librarian CLIEEORD LEWIS, 3RD

Committees

NUMISMATICS

GARRETT L. REILLY ALERED D. NORRIS EDWARD HOOPES

genealogy

S. W. WOODHOUSE, JR. ERANKLIN BACHE HENRY PLEASANTS, JR.

PUBLICATION

HORACE W. CASTOR LAWRENCE J. MORRIS JULIAN P. BOYD

FINANCE

CHARLES E. JENKINS CLIEEORD LEWIS, JR.

J. HENRY SCATTERGOOD

ANTIQUITIES

CALEB J. MILNE, JR. WARREN MILNE ARTHUR L. BYE

LIBRARY

WM. S. ASHBROOK WALTER S. McINNES MERLE M. ODGERS

MEMBERSHIP

BENJAMIN R. HOEEMAN PERCIVAL EOERDERER C. S. ASHBY HENRY

PROGRA M

HOWARD LONGSTRETH S. W. WOODHOUSE, JR. GREVILLE HASLAM

11

1940

OFFICERS

President

HOWARD LONGSTRETH

Vice-Presidents

J. STOGDELL STOKES LAWRENCE J. MORRIS

RICHARD PETERS, JR. RICHARD E. NORTON

Recording Secretary

Corresponding Secretary

Treasurer

Historiographer

Curator of Numismatics

Assistant Curator of Numismatics

Curator of Antiquities

Librarian

HENRY PAUL BUSCH HENRY PAUL BUSCH BENJAMIN R. HOEFMAN GARRETT L. REILLY RICHARD E. NORTON ALFRED D. NORRIS F. LYNWOOD GARRISON CLIFFORD LEWIS, 3RD

Com mittees

NUMISMATICS

GARRETT L. REILLY ALFRED D. NORRIS EDWARD HOOPES

GENEALOGY

S. W. WOODHOUSE, JR. FRANKLIN BACHE HENRY PLEASANTS, JR.

PUBLICATION

HORACE W. CASTOR LAWRENCE J. MORRIS JULIAN P. BOYD

IT\AN( E

CHARLIES F. JENKINS CLIFI'ORD LIiWIS, JR.

J. HENRY SCATTERIIOOD

ANTIQUITIES

CALEB J. MILNE, JR. WARREN MILNE ARTHUR L. BYE

LIBRARY

WM. S. ASHBROOK JANSEN HAINES MERLE M. ODGERS

MEMBERSHIP

BENJAMIN R. HOFFMAN PERCIVAL E. FOERDERER C. S. ASHBY HENRY

PROGRAM

HOWARD LONGSTRETH S. W. WOODHOUSE, JR. CREVILLE HASLAM

12

1941

OFFICERS

President

HOWARD LONGSTKETH

Vice-Presidents

J. STOGDELL STOKES PRICHARD PETERS. JR.

Recording Secretary

Corrcspo)iding Secretary

T reasurcr , .

Historiographer

Curator of Numismatics

Assistant Curator of Numismatics

Curator of Antiquities

Librarian

lawrp:nce j. morris

RICHARD E. NORTON

HENRY PAUL BUSCH HENRY PAUL BUSCH BENJAMIN R. HOFEMAN GARRETT L. REILLY RICHARD E. NORTON ALFRED D. NORRIS F. LYNWOOD GARRISON CLIFFORD LEWIS, 3RD

Com mittees

NUMISMATICS

GARRETT L. REILLY ALFRED D. NORRIS PHILIP H. WARD, JR.

GENEALOGY

FRANKLIN BACHE HENRY PLEASANTS, JR. DEXTER A. TUTEIN

PUBLICATION

HORACE W. CASTOR L.WVRENCE J. MORRIS GARRETT L. REILLY

FINANCE

CHARLES F. JENKINS CLIFFORD LEWIS, JR.

J. HENRY SCATTERGOOD

*Died Feb. 15, 1941

ANTIQUITIES

CALEB J. MILNE, JR. WARREN MILNE ARTH*UR L. BYE

LIBRARY

M. WISTAR WOOD CLIFFORD LEWIS, 3RD MERLE M. ODGERS

membership

BENJAMIN R. HOFFMAN PERCIVAL E. FOERDERER C. S. ASHBY HENRY

PROGRAM

JANSEN HAINES

S. W. WOODHOUSE. JR.

GREVILLE HASLAM

13

1942

OFFICERS

President

HOWARD LONGSTRETH

Vice-Presidents

J. STOGDELL STOKES LAWRENCE J. MORRIS

F. LYNWOOD GARRISON RICHARD E. NORTON

Recording Secretary

Corrcspo)iding Secretary

Treasurer

Historiographer

Curator of N umisinatics

.Issistant Curator of N umismatics

Curator of Antiquities

Librarian

*HENRY PAUL BUSCH tM. WISTAR WOOD *HENRY PAUL BUSCH tM. WISTAR WOOD WILLIAM J. PHILLIPS GARRETT L. REILLY RICHARD E. NORTON ALFRED D. NORRIS F. LYNWOOD GARRISON CLIFFORD LEWIS, 3RD

Committees

NUMISMATICS

GARRETT L. REILLY ALl'RED D. NORRIS PHILIP H. WARD, JR.

(lENEALOGY

FRANKLIN BACHE HENRY PLEASANTS, JR. DEXTER A. TUTEIN

I’UHLICATIO.N

HORACE W. CASTOR LAWRENCE J. MORRIS GARRETT L. REILLY

HNAN( E

CIIARLICS F. JENKINS CLIFFORD LEWIS, JR.

J. HICNRY SCATTERGOOD

ANTIQUITIES

THEODORE E. WIEDERSEIM WARREN MILNE ARTHUR E. BYE

U DR ARY

M. WISTAR WOOD CLIFFORD LEWIS. 3RD MERLE M. ODGERS

MEMBERS II ID

BENJAMIN R. HOFFMAN PERCiVAL f:. FOERDERER C. S. ASHBY HENRY

PROGRAM

JANSEN HAINES FTSKE S. KIMBALL GRIWILLE HASLAM

NOMINATING

GARRICn- L. RF.ILLY PI-:RCIVAL

CLIFFORD LEWIS. JR.

EOERDERIHt

*I)i(-(l Apr. 24, 1942 tl'.lcctcil June 4, 1942

14

1943

OFFICERS

President

HOWARD LONGSTRETH

Vice-Presidents

J. STOGDELL STOKES LAWRENCE J. MORRIS

F. LYNWOOD GARRISON RICHARD E. NORTON

Recording Secretary

Corresponding Secretary

Treasurer

Historiographer

Curator of Ahintisniatics

Assistant Curator of N^uniisinatics

Curator of Antiquities

Librarian

M. W I STAR WOOD M. WTSTAR WOOD WILLIAM J. PHILLIPS GARRETT L. REILLY RICHARD E. NORTON ALFRED D. NORRIS F. LYNWOOD GARRISON CLIFFORD LEWIS, 3RD

Committees

NUMISMATICS

GARRETT L. REILLY ALFRED D. NORRIS

GENEALOGY

FRANKLIN BACHE HENRY PLEASANTS, JR. CHARLES F. GRIFFITH

PUBLICATION

HORACE W. CASTOR LAWRENCE J. MORRIS DR. JAMES W'. WISTER

FINANCE

CHARLES F. JENKINS CLIFFORD LEWIS, JR.

J. HENRY SCATTERGOOD

ANTIQUITIES

THEODORE E. WIEDERSEIM WARREN MILNE ARTHUR E. BYE

LIBRARY

M. WISTAR WOOD CLIFFORD LEWIS. 3RD MERLE M. ODGERS

MEMBERSHIP

BENJAMIN R. HOFFMAN PERCIVAL E. FOERDERER C. S. ASHBY HENRY

PROGRAM

JANSEN HAINES FISKE S. KIMBALL GREVILLE HASLAM

NOMINATING

GARRETT L. REILLY PERCIVAL E. FOERDERER

CLIFFORD LEWIS, JR.

1944

OFFICERS

President

HOWARD LONGSTRETH

Vice-Presidents

J. STOGDELL STOKES LAWRENCE J. MORRIS

F. LYNWOOD GARRISON RICHARD E. NORTON

Recording Secretary M. WISTAR WOOD

Corresponding Secretary M. WISTAR WOOD

Treasurer WILLIAM J. PHILLIPS

Historiographer GARRF3TT L. REILLY

Curator of Numismatics .ALFRED D. NORRIS

Assistant Curator of N umismaties SAMUEL A. TATNALL

Curator of Antiquities F. LYNWOOD GARRISON

I.ibrarian CLIFFORD LEWIS, 3RD

Com mittees

A.NTigUITlES

THEODORE E. WIEDERSEIM WARREN MILNE ARTHUR E. BYE

NUMISM.MICS

RICI-IARD F:. NORTON ALFRED D. NORRIS SAMUEL A. TATNALL

GENEALOGY

FRANKLIN BACHE HENRY PLEASANTS. JR. CHARLES F. GRIFFITH

I’Um.ICATIO.N

HORACE W. CASTOR LAWRENCE J. MORRIS DR. JAMES W. WISTER

FINANCE

CHARLES F. JENKINS CLII'FORD LEWIS, JR.

J. HENRY SCATTERGOOD

LIBRARY

M. WISTAR WOOD CLIFFORD LEWIS, 3RD MERLE M. ODGERS

MEMBERSHIP

BENJAMIN R. HOFFMAN PERCIVAL E. FOERDERER C. S. ASHBY HENRY

PROGRA M

GREVILLE HASLAM

JOSEPH A. DAVIS

DR. J0SF:PH MiF'ARLAND

GAR RICT'r

NOMINATING

I'^IGLLY PERCIVAL E.

CLHH<ORD LEWIS. JR.

i-oerderi-:r

16

1945

OFFICERS

President

HOWARD LONGSTRETH

V ICE- Presidents

J. STOGDELL STOKES E. LYNWOOD GARRISON

Recording Secretary

Corresf’0)idi)i(/ Secretary

Treasurer

Historiographer

Curator of N uuiis)uatics

Assistant Curator of iSuniismatics

Curator of Antiquities

Librariaji

LAWRENCE J. MORRIS RICHARD E. NORTON

M. W I STAR WOOD- M. W I STAR WOOD WILLIAM J. PHILLIPS GARRETT L. REILLY ALERED D. NORRIS SAMUEL A. TATNALL E. LYNWOOD GARRISON SYMINGTON P. LANDRETH, JR.

Com mittees

numismatics RICHARD E. NORTON ALERED D. NORRIS SAMUEL A. TATNALL

genealogy

ERANKLIN BACHE HENRY PLEASANTS, JR. CHARLES E. GRIEEITH

publication

HORACE W. CASTOR LAWRENCE J. MORRIS DR. JAMES W. WISTER

FINANCE

CHARLES E. JENKINS CLIEEORD LEWIS, JR.

J. HENRY SCATTERGOOD

ANTIQUITIES

THEODORE E. WIEDERSEIM EDWIN W. SEMANS MALCOLM LLOYD, JR.

LIBRARY

DR. MERLE M. ODGERS CLIEEORD LEWIS, 3RD J. ROY CARROLL, JR.

MEMBERSHIP

BENJAMIN R. HOEEMAN PERCIVAL E. FOERDERER C. S. ASHBY HENRY

PROGRA M

JOSEPH A. DAVIS GREVILLE HASLAM DR. JOSEPH McFarland

NOMINATING

GARRETT L. REILLY ALBERT NALLE

SAMUEL BUNTING LEWIS

17

RESIDENT MEMBERS

Elected

1926 Bache, Franklin, R. D. #2, West Chester, Pa.

1945 Bromley, Brooks, 31 E. Sum-

mitt Avenue, Phila. 19.

1942 Butler, Thomas Richard, Goshen Rd., Newtown Square (U. S. N avy ) .

1926 Bye, Dr. Arthur Edwin, Holi- cong. Pa.

1941 Carroll. J. Roy, Jr., 1420 Wal-

nut St., Phila. 2.

1931 Carson, Joseph, 636 Winsford

Rd., Bryn Mawr, Pa.

1937 Casey, Herbert S., Windermere Ct.. Wayne, Pa. (overseas Red Cross).

1937 Castor, Horace W., 1700 Sansom St., Phila. 3.

1944 Chester, Dr. Allan G., 504 Berk- ley Rd., Narberth, Pa.

1939 Coates, M. Vernon, Colonial Inn, Bryn Mawr, Pa.

1912 Colket, G. Hamilton, 322 Crest Rd., Ridgewood, N. J.

1917 *Colket, Tristram C., 2nd, Mt. Moro Rd., Villa Nova.. Pa.

1942 Davis. Joseph A., Girard Col-

lege, Phila. 21.

1946 Dicke, Harold P., Esq., Packard

Bldg., Phila. 2.

1934 Du Barry, William H., Barclay,

Rittenhouse Square, Phila. 3.

1935 Evans, Thomas, School House

Lane W. of Henry Ave., Gtn.

1932 *Foerderer, Percival E., Bryn

Mawr, Pa.

1920 Garrison, F. Lynwood, 1019 Clinton St., Phila. 7.

1917 *Gillingham, Harrold E., 432 W. Price St., Gtn., Phila. 27.

1939 Griffith, Charles E., 520 Com-

merce St., I’hila. 6.

1941 Haines, Casper Wistar, 8620 IWergreen PI., Chestnut Hill 18.

1940 Hart, Thomas, 271 Hathaway

Lane, Wynncwood, Pa.

19.16 Haslam, Greville, h'pi.s copal Academy, City Line Ave., Ovcrbrook, Phila.

19.16 Henry C. S. Ashby, Mill Creek Rfl., Gladwyne. Pa.

1922 Ilf)ffman, Benjamin 11., 2131

Land Title Bldg., Phila. 10.

‘ I. iff ineniljcr.

Elected

1920 *Hoopes, Edward, Upper Beaches, West Chester, Pa., Box 2.

1946 Hopkins, Arthur M., 8 Toho- peka Court, Phila. 18.

1924 M^ffreys, Harry L., 121 Valley Rd., Ardmore, Pa.

1923 *Jenkins, Charles E., Kitchen’s Lane, Mt. Airy, Phila. 19.

1918 *Kelsey, Albert, Quogue — Long Island, N. Y.

1926 Kimball, Dr. Eiske, Phila. Mu- seum of Art, Parkway at 26th, Phila. 30.

1942 Landreth, Symington P., J r.,

1400 So. Penn Square, Phila.

2.

1930 Lea, Robert C., 51 Re.x Ave., Chestnut Hill, Phila. 18.

1929 *Lewis, Alfred G. Baker, P. O. Box 682 — Grand Central An- nex, N. Y. 17.

1933 Lewis, Clifford, Jr., 240 S. 4th St., Phila. 6.

1938 Lewis, Clifford, 3rd, 240 S. 4th

St., Phila. 6.

1929 *Lewis, John E., Jr., 1916 Spruce St., Phila. 3. -

1943 Lewis, Samuel Bunting, Union

League, Phila. 2.

1942 Lloyd, Malcolm, Jr., 1930 Land

Title Bldg., Phila. 10.

1943 Longacre, J. Barton, 435 Walnut

St., Phila. 6.

1909 Longstreth, Howard, Haverford, Pa.

1939 Machold, William F., 2605 — 36th

Place, N. W., Washington 7, D. C.

1935 *Mcllhenny, Henry P., Lincoln Dr. and Johnson St., Phila. 44 (USN).

1941 Mendenhall, Dr. John C., 4734 Penn St., h'rankford, Phila. 24.

1944 Minds, John 11., 1900 Ritten-

hou.se Scj.

1935 *Milne, Warren, 1549 Ponce de Leon Dr., h'ort Lauderdale, h'la.

1928 *Morris, Lawrence J., 240 S. 4th St., Phila. 6.

1939 Myers, Charles, 427 Midland Ave., St. Davids, Pa.

18

Elected

1941 Nalle. Albert. 1401 Arch St.. Phila. 5.

1935 Norris, Alfred D., 820 Old Buck Lane, Haverford, Pa.

1916 Norris, Charles C., Jr., 1500

Walnut St., Phila. 2.

1935 Norton, Richard E., 1429 Wal- nut St., Phila. 2.

1938 Odgers, Dr. Merle Middleton, Girard College, Phila. 21.

1899 Pfahler, Alfred E., The Union

I Pnll3 /

1940 Philips, Dr. Wiiliam J., 126 Up-

land Terrace, Bala-Cynwvd, Pa.

1937 Pleasants, Dr. Henry, Jr., 18 W. Chestnut St., West Chester. Pa.

1941 Price, Eli Kirk, III, 129 Beth-

lehem Pike, Chestnut Hill, Phila. 18. (U. S. Service). 1910 Reilly Garrett L., Rosemont, Pa.

1917 Scattergood, J. Henry. Villa

Nova, Pa.

1935 Schumann. Dr. Edward A., 1814 Spruce St., Phila. 3.

1941 Semans, Edwin W., 1221 Med- ford Rd., Wynnewood, Pa.

*Life member.

Elected

1944 Sturgis, Dr. Samuel B., 34 W. Montgomerv Ave., Ardmore, Pa.

1925 Stokes, J. Stogdell, Huntingdon Valley, Pa.

1943 Tatnall, Samuel A., 418 W. School Lane, Phila. 44.

1939 Tutein, Dexter A., 57 Summit

Ave., Chestnut Hill, Phila. 18.

1940 Ward, Philip H.. Jr., 1616 Wal-

nut St., Phila. 3.

1912 Wetherill, Webster K., Bryn Mawr Tr. Co., Brvn Mawr, Pa.

1939 Whiting, Allen E., The Drake,

1512 Spruce St., Phila. 2.

1938 Wiederseim, Theodore E., 413

Arch St., Phila. 6.

1940 Wiederseim, William C., Old

York Rd., Abington, Pa.

1941 Wister, Dr. James W.. 5430 Ger-

mantown x\ve., Phila. 44.

1939 Wood, Morris Wistar, 7406 Ger-

mantown Ave., Mt. Airy, Phila. 19.

1936 Woolman, Edward, 700 Pan- mure Rd., Haverford, Pa.

19

NECROLOGY

HON. GEORGE HENDERSON Januarv 28, 1936

CLARENCE B. MOORE March 24. 1936

JOHN GRIBBEL August 25. 1936

PROF. GIUSEPPE SERGI (Corresponding Member) . . . .October 17, 1936

REV. ARTHUR C. CARTY November 29, 1937

FREDERICK D. LANGENHEIM December 10, 1937

HOWL.A.ND WOOD (Corresponding Member) January 3, 1938

SIR PAUL CLIAYTER (Corresponding Member)

JOSEPH G. LESTER April 24. 1938

RICHARD WISTAR DAVIDS July 1, 1939

JOHN W. TOWNSEND December 5, 1939

\V M. \V. HERNE December 19, 1939

J. BERTRAM LIPPINCOTT (President of Society) ... .January 19. 1940

WALTER S. MeINNES May 13, 1940

RICHARD PETERS, JR I'ebruary 15, 1941

CALEB JONES MILNE. JR May 23, 1941

JAMES RUSSELL HARRIS March 9M942

HENRY PAUL BUSCH f April 24M942

DK. SAMUEL \\ . WOODHOXJSI'L, JR February 3, 1943

D. JANSEN HAINES March 17 1943

I-: I) W A R D ROBINS M ay 22! 1 943

W.M. J.\Y TURNER December 2, 1943

DR. CHARLES W. BURR February 21 1944

DR. GEORGE CLAPP VAILLANT May 13* 1945

ERNEST SPOFFORD Iune7 l945

JOHN M. SCOTT October 1945

CARROLL SMYTH June 16, 1945

DR. JOSIHMI McFarland September 22. 1945

20

MEETINGS HELD, AND I’Al’ERS (HVEN BEEORE THE SOCIETY 1936-1945

Date

1936 1 lost and Location

Jan. 27. Henry Bartol Brazier, Merion Cricket Chib.

h'eb. 24. Walter S. Mclnnes, Esq., 1808 Spruce Street.

Mar. 23. Richard E. Norton,

Green Hill Earms.

.May 13. J. Henry Scattergood,

“Dnndale,” Villa Nova.

June 18. J. Stogdell Stokes,

“Spring Valley Farm,’’ Huntingdon Valley.

Nov. 23. J. Bertram Lippincott.

1712 Spruce Street.

1937

Jan. 25. E. Lynwood Garrison, 1019 Clinton Street.-

Mar. 22. William S. Ashbrook, Franklin Inn Club.

.May 21. Charles F. Jenkins,

“Far Country,” Germantown.

June 4. Benjamin R. Hoffman, “The Grange,”

West Overbrook.

Oct. 18. Howard Longstreth, “Dove Hill House.” Haverford.

Nov. 22. J. Bertram Lippincott.

1712 Spiuce Street.

1938

Jan. 24. Lawrence J. Morris, Rittenhouse Club.

Feb. 25. Edward Woolman, Historical Society,

13th and Locust Sts.

*Puhlishecl in Vol. 32.

Paper and .-Xiithor

Mr. Alfred Norris — Address on “Mints and Coinage of the United States.”*

H. V. Brewington. Esq. — .\ddrcss on “Nicholas Biddle of the Continental

A 15

rmy.

Mr. Norton — Address on “The Elli- cott Clock.”*

Mr. Scattergood — Address on “The WTrk of the Government for the Indians.”

Mr. Stokes — Address on “Old Fur- niture and the Collecting of It.”

Mr. Charles Lyon Chandler — Address on “A Statesman a Hundred Years Ago — Joel R. Poinsette as Secre- tary of War 1837-1841.”

Prof. C. R. Morey — Address on “Ex- cavation of Antioch-on-the-Orontes.” {lUustrotcd)

Mr. Horace W. Castor — Address on “Colonial Frankford.”

Mr. Jenkins conducted the members through his arboretum and described the collection of Hemlocks.

Mr. Robert Wheelwright — .A.ddress on “Colonial Gardens of Philadelphia.”

Boise Penrose, 3rd — Address on “Early Transportation as Illustrated by Old Prints.”

Mr. Lewis F. Tabor — Address on “History and Development of the Photographic Process.”

Mr. Morris — .A.ddress on “Chinese Porcelain.”

Dr. John A. Wilson, Director, The Oriental Institute, Univ. of Chicago • — Address on “The Work of the Oriental Institute in the Near East.”

21

Date

Host and Location

Apr. 25. Henry P. Mcllhenny, Lincoln Drive and Johnson Street.

May 16. Arthur Edwin Bye, Holicong, Pa.

June 6. Joseph Carson,

Winsford Road, Bryn Mawr.

Nov. 2. Franklin Bachc and Henry Pleasants, Jr., Conestoga Pike. Chester County.

Nov. 28. Garrett L. Reilly, The Art Club.

1939

Jan. 23. Richard E. Norton,

Green Hill Farms.

Apr. 3. Clifford Lewis, Jr.,

30 S. 22nd Street.

May 10. Caleb J. Milne, Jr.,

6611 Wissahickon Ave.

May 31. Merle Middleton Odgers, h'ranklin Inn Club.

Nov. 27. Jansen Haines,

Wistar Institute,

36tb and Woodland Avenue.

1940

Jan. 22. Horace W. Castor,

Architects Building.

Mar. 25. Richard Peters, Jr., anti C. .S. .Ashby Henry, .'\rcbitects Building.

.\pr. 22. Alfred 1). Norris,

Union League.

Paper and Author

Mr. Mcllhenny — Address on “The French Paintings in His Collection.’’

Dr. Bye exhibited and described his collection of Paintings and anticpies, and told “The Story of San Diego as told by Don Ramondo Miranda.’’

Mr. Carson showed and described his XVIII Century Furniture, Prints and Lowestoft.

Mr. Bache exhibited Frankliniana in his collection.

Dr. Pleasants — Address on “Some Phases of the American Revolution.”

Dr. Edward E. Wildman, Director of Science Education, Phila. Public Schools — Address on “Living Sou- venirs of William Penn’s Day.”

Mr. Sherman Rogers — Address on “Where Do We Go From Here.”

Scully Bradley, PhD. — Address on “Native American Humor.”

Visit to the Germantown Historical Society for inspection of Museum and Library, followed by visit to Mr. Milne’s home.

Inspection of new Central High School Building.

Later, Dr. John L. Haney, President, delivered an address on “The His- tory of the Central High School and its Contributions to Philadelphia.”

Mr. Haines — Address on “The Back- ground and Antecedents of the Wis- tar Institute of Anatomy and Bi- ology.”

Dr. Edmund J. I'arris, Director of the Institute, spoke of recent and cur- rent activities.

Mr. Harold Donaldson Eherlcin — Ad- dress on “Our Visible Historical llcritage.” (lUusIralcd)

Air. Philip H. Warrl, Jr. — Address on Postal b r;inks of the l^rcsidcnts. ”

Mr. La S. Reed — A<ldrcss on “Amer- ican Coins and Stiegel Glass.”

22

Date

Host and r,ocatioii

May 15. Howard Longstrctli,

Dove Mill House,

Haver ford, Pa.

June 5. Henry Paul Busch, Pennsbury, Pa.

Xov. 25. Morris Wistar Wood,

Penna School for the Deaf, Chestnut Hill.

Dec. 12. Franklin Institute.

1941

Jan. 27. F. Lynwood Garrison,

1019 Clinton Street.

Feb. 24. Greville Haslam,

The Episcopal Academy, Overbrook, Phila.

Alar. 24. Richard E. Norton and Clifford Lewis, 3rd,

Atwater Kent Museum of History.

May 7. Herbert S. Casey,

Old Spring Mill Road, Villa Nova.

June 4. Percival E. Foerderer,

“La Ronda,”

Bryn Mawr.

Oct. 27. Theodore E. Wiederseim and William C. Wiederseim, Mask and Wig Club.

1942

Jan. 26. Garrett L. Reilly,

University Club.

Mar. 2. Richard E. Norton,

Green Hill Farms, Overbrook.

Mar. 30. Warren Alilne,

Philadelphia Country Club.

June 4. Dr. William J. Phillips, Lenape Club.

Oct. 12. J. Henrv Scattergood, “Dundale,”

Villa Nova.

I'apiT and .Author

H. L. Crosby, Ph.D. — -Address on "Greece Revisited." (Illustrated)

Mr. Busch — Address on “William Penn's Manor and Its Restoration.”

Mr. Wood — Address on “The History and Present Work of the Pennsyl- vania School for the Deaf.”

Meeting to consider the possibility of a permanent e.xhibition of Coins, Stamps and Autographs in the City of Philadelphia.

Dr. Joseph AlcFarland — Address on “Ex Libris Medici.”

Mr. Haslam and other Headmasters addressed the Society on “Ancient Private Academies of Philadelphia, their Origins and Eccentricities.”

Dr. Horace G. Haviland — Address on “The Story of the Select School.”

Dr. Merle Middleton Odgers — Ad- dress on “Stephen Girard and His Eoundation.”

Air. Daniel Pratt Alannix, Jr. — Ad- dress on “The History of Magic and Deception.”

Air. Eoerderer exhibited and ex- plained the history of some of his Spanish pieces, with some brief references to Addison Alizner.

Air. Thomas Ridgway — Address on “The Eirst Theatres of Philadel- phia.”

Air. F. Lynwood Garrison — Address on “Use of Gold in Coinage.”

Air. John A. Stevenson — Address on “Franklin Looks at ’42.”

Charles J. Hepburn, Esq. — Address on “Alayan Architecture.”

Air. Horace Alather Lippincott — Ad- dress on “Old Houses of Philadel- phia.”

Air. Scattergood — Address on “The French Spoliation Claims.”

23

Date

Host and Location

Xov. 6. Jansen Haines,

“Wyck,”

6026 Germantown Ave.

1943

Jan. 25. Law'rence J. Morris, Rittenhouse Club.

Mar. 1. Charles F. Griffith,

The Racquet Club.

Mar. 29 Dr. Merle Middleton Odgers, Franklin Inn Club.

-Apr. 27. Horace W. Castor,

Union League.

May 18. Howard Longstreth,

"Dove Mill House,” Haverford.

June 9. Benjamin R. Hoffman, “The Grange,”

West Overbrook.

Xov. 29. Greville Haslam,

C. S. Ashby Henr\q Dr. James W. Wister, Franklin Inn Club.

1944

Jan. 24. .Mien F. Whiting,

Union League.

I'eb. 28. Malcolm Lloyd, Jr. and .Mbert Xalle,

Rittenhouse Club.

Mar. 27. Dr. Joseph McFarland and .Morris Wistar Wood,

Penna. School for the Deaf, Chestnut Hill.

.\l)r. 24. Thomas Evans and

I )r. James W. Wister.

.Mask and Wig Club.

.May 24. Clifford Lewis, Jr. and Clifford 1 .ew'is, 3rd, 240 S. 4th Street.

Dec. 18. h.flwin W. Semans ancl Joseph A. Davis,

Union League.

Paper and Author

Motion Picture — “From New Lands to Old.”

Mr. Morris — Address on “Earliest Philadelphia Silversmiths.”

Mr. Hall — Motion Picture wdth sound effects — “From Miami to Buenos .A,ires by American .A.irlines Clip- per.”

Dr. Wm. J. Phillips — .\ddress — “Old Wonders in a New World.”

Mr. Alfred Norris showed a small collection of coins and spoke infor- mally about them.

Air. Castor — Address on “A Pine Street Church and Frankford Gun- powder in Colonial Days.”

Air. Lessing Rosenwald — Address on “Numismatic and Antiquarian Sub- jects.” Illustrated by Engravings and Prints from his collection.

Air. Hoffman — Address — “Notes on The Grange — a Colonial Country House.”

Air. Richard T. Hoober — Address — “Denarii of the Tw'elve Caesars.”

Air. Carl Zigrosser — Address — “What Are Prints?”

Air. Jvdian P. Boyd — Address — “Thomas Jefferson’s Letters and Papers."

Dr. McFarland — Address on “The Yellow Fever h?pidcmic and Dr. Benjamin Rush.”

Air. Thomas Flart — Informal Address — “The Schuylkill Fishing Conqjany in the County of Philadeli)hia, some- times knowm as the State in Schuyl- kill.”

.Mr. Clifford Lewis, Jr. — Address — “Old Philadeli)hi;i Newsi)ai)ers be- tw'ceu Yorktow'u and the Peace.”

C aptain Stephen C. Rowan — .Address — “Ships — Old and Ncw\”

24

Date

1945 Host ami l.ocation

Jan. 22. Henry Pleasants. J r. and Charles Myers,

University Clnh.

Feb. 26. J. Roy Carroll, Jr., University Clnb.

Mar. 26. Samuel Bunting Lewis and Charles C. Norris. Jr., Union League.

May 1. J. Barton Longacre and M. Vernon Coates, Rittenhouse Club.

Nov. 30. Edward Woolman, University Club.

Paper and Author

Dr. Pleasants — Address — “The First Munitions Smuggler of the Revolu- tion” with exhibits.

Mr. Carroll — Address — “Historical Backgrounds for Contemporary Architectural Design.”

Dr. Desiderio Roman — Address — “Russian Surgery.”

Dr. George C. Vaillant — Address — • “The Indian Background of Ameri- can History.” (Illustrated)

^Ir. C. E. Earis — Address — “The Navajo Indian.”

25

CABINET

Number of Coins, Medals, Notes, etc. deposited with the Pennsylvania Museum at Memorial Hall

Previously recorded . .

Under receipt No. 297

Receipts for which are in the custody of your Curator Total Accessions since last deposit — -

Coins and Tokens 155

Medals 8

Notes, Paper and Wooden Money 10 173

10,678

173 10,851

Made up as follows : — Purchases

Coins and Tokens

57

Medals

4

Notes

10

71

Donations

By Individuals

Coins and Tokens 98"

Medals 4

Notes 0 102

173

Curator has in his Custody

Brinton Medals 3

Dana Medals 3

26

BEQUESTS

Under the will of Prof. Charles E. Dana, lately President, the Society was left a bequest of $1,000.

Under the will of Mr. John T. Morris, a former President, the Society was left a bequest of $1,000.

THE MAXWFJ.E SOALMERVILEE BEQUEST

Under the will of Professor Sommerville. a former Vice-President, the Society was bequeathed $1,000 and a proportionate share in the residuary estate. On September 5, 1905, the Society received from the executors the sum of $1,864.18. On January 8, 1910, a further sum of $137.39 was received, making the total amount $2,001.57.

This money now forms part of the Permanent Fund, the income alone being used for the expenses of the Society.

THE CHARLES J. COHEN PUBLICATION FUND

This Fund was started in April, 1919, by Mr. Charles J. Cohen with a gift of $1,000, to which, according to the stipulation of the donor, shall be added all interest earned by the Fund and such accretions as may occur from time to time, until such time as the Fund shall equal $10,000, after which the interest therefrom may be used towards the defraying of the expenses of the publications of the Society. This fund amounts to $1,300.

27

J. HKRTRAM LIIMMNCOTT 1857 - 1940

President of The Nuinismafic and Anti(|iiarian Society — 1956-1940

J. BERTRAM ElRlTNari'T

Oil Jamiary 19. 1940, Joshua Bertram Lijipincott, President of the Numismatic and Antiquarian Society, died at his home, 1712 Spruce Street, at the a^e of eighty-two. He was a Vice- President of the Society from 1926 to 1935, and President from 1936 to the time of his death. He entertained the Society many times at his home when his kindly personality and hospitality made these meetings memorahle.

Mr. Lippincott was horn at the family summer home in Huntingdon Valley on August 24, 1857. He graduated from the Episcopal Academy in 1874, and entered the Class of 1878 at the University of Pennsylvania. He was elected President of the Board of the Veterinary Hospital in 1906. The University of Pennsylvania conferred upon him the degree of Bachelor of Arts in 1906, and in 1935 the honorary degree of Doctor of Laws.

Entering the publishing business of J. B. Lippincott and Company, he was admitted to the firm in 1884. He became Vice- President in 1886, President in 1910, and Chairman of the Board in 1926. A number of periodicals were published under his super- vision.

On April 22, 1885, he married Joanna Wharton, daughter of Joseph Wharton, and later became Vice-President of the Wharton Steel Company. In 1895 IVIr. Lippincott became a director of the Bethlehem Iron Works, and also of the Academy of Music, of which he served later as Vice-President. He was a director and for a time President, of the Mercantile Library, and a director of the Farmers and Mechanics Bank. He also served as a director of the Board of Trade and of the Athenaeum Library. He was a member of the American Philosophical Society and served on the Council for a long period.

On his farm in Montgomery County, Mr. Lippincott raised thoroughbred animals and poultry, and he was a leader in the Philadelphia Society for Promoting Agriculture.

His clubs included The Players, Publishers’ Lunch, Bachelors Barge, Art. Corinthian Yacht. University. Country Club, Hunt- ingdon Valley, Union League and Franklin Inn. Of the Union League he was a director 1905-1907. Of the Eranklin Inn he was one of the founders.

29

HENRY PAUL BUSCH

Secretary of The Numismatic and Antiquarian Society

1934-1942

Air. Henry Paul Busch who lived at 1006 Spruce Street, died April 24, 1942. He was prominent in civic affairs for many years. He was President of the Colonial Society of Pennsylvania, and of the Welcome Society of Pennsylvania, since 1922, and was interested in genealogical research, and in the affairs of many city clubs and societies.

He attended the Rittenhouse Academy and the University of Pennsylvania, from which he graduated in 1898, in Chemistry. A short time later he entered the firm of Shoemaker and Busch. He was president of the Company from 1925 to 1929, and a di- rector at the time of his death.

He was long active in the affairs of the Numismatic and Antiquarian Society, and served as its Secretary from 1934 until his death.

Air. Busch was treasurer of the Genealogical Society of Pennsylvania, and a member of the Union League, University Club, and the Philadelphia Country Club.

He was also a member of the Geographical Society of Phila- delphia, and at one time a vice-])resident ; a member of the Penn- sylvania Society Sons of the Revolution, Society of the War of 1812, Society of Colonial Wars, Netherlands Society of Pennsyl- vania, Historical Society of Pennsylvania, Lairmount Park Art Association, and numerous Chemical Societies.

He is survived by his wife, the former Lydia Learning Smith, a daughter Lmilie Smith Busch, and a brother, Aliers Busch.

30

EARLY SHIPBUILDING IN PHILADEF.PHIA (Read of a meeting of the Soeiety, Sovember 27, 1923)

By Charles Lyon Chandler

Even before William Penn had arrived in America, he had provided in his ‘‘Conditions Agreed upon with the Settlers” in 1681 that in clearing the land all good oak trees shonld he pre- served for ship])ing,^ and he directed his first Commission, which was to lay ont Philadelphia, to select a site on the Delaware where “it is most navigable, dry and healthy ; that is, where most ships can best ride, of deepest draught of water, if possible to load or unload at the hank or quayside without boating or lightering.”- That this program was duly carried out is evident from the fact that four years later, in October, 1685, there were shipwrights and hoatwrights, ropemakers, sailmakers, and hlockmakers in Philadelphia, — Penn expressly stating that “some vessels have been here built, and many boats; and by that means (we have) a ready convenience for the passage of people and goods.” William West, who came over with Penn had already begun his career by building a vessel for Penn at his shipyard near what was known as the Penny-Pot Landing, at the foot of Vine Street in Philadelphia. The ro])e walks, sail and hlockmakers’ shops ex- tended from just above the foot of Market Street almost con- tinuously to this yard of West’s at Vine Street Wharf, which had been obtained by West in part payment for a vessel built for Penn.-*^ Although Philadelphia’s ]X)pulation did not exceed 3,000 in 1690, they included 3 master shipcarpenters, one ropemaker, making ropes for shipping, and four master coopers that made an abundance of casks for the sea.”-

In the well-known description of Philadelphia written by Gabriel Thomas in 1698, he describes her shipbuilding industry as follows: “Now the true reason why this Fruitful country and Florishing city advance so considerably in the purchase of lands both in one and the other is their great and extended trafigue and commerce both by sea and land,” adding that “They (the in-

^Cheyney, E. P., “Shipbuilding on the Delaware River,” Harrisburg, 1891.

-Myers, Albert Cook, “Narratives of Early Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Delaware,” Scribners, 1912.

■■^Scharff & Westcott, Vol. Ill, p. 2336; Moody, “Historical Outline of Shipbuilding in Philadelphia,” Philadelphia, 1926.

31

habitants of Penn’s new Colony) have curious wharfs as also large and fine timber yards both at Philadelphia and New Castle, especially at the metropolis (Philadelphia) before Robert Turner’s Great and Famous House, where are built ships of considerable burthen,” while elsewhere in his detailed narrative we learn that “they have very stately oaks to build ships with, some of which are between fifty and sixty feet long, and clear from knots, being very straight and well-grained,” and what is even more important, that “Some ships of two or three hundred tons each” had been built on Dock Creek by 1698!!^ Since the average ship built in England was less than 200 tons in 17,31, 33 years later, we can gather how far Penn’s colony had progressed, and Richard Castle- man, writing in 1710 of Pennsylvania, remarks of Philadelphia: “There are several caves and docks where large shi])s are built ; and, by a moderate computation, there has l)een launched from the stocks of this city in fortv years near 300 sail ships, besides small craft, which may in some sort give us an idea of the opu- lency of the place.

Philadelphia’s piracy deserves mention. In the year 1697 Thomas Robinson declared that ])i rates walked the streets of Philadeli)hia in ])erfect safety; and two years previously a Phila- del])hian. Captain John Want, was one of a goodly company of four ])irates who went from the British American Colonies to Madagascar. Cai)tain Want is said to have made a profit of ap- ])roximately the equivalent of a million dollars in our money today on this crui.se, on his good ship Dolphin, which was burnt at Madagascar in 1695.“

The few existing statistics of Colonial shipbuilding are in the following table :

Total

Tonnage

1722

10

428

1723

13

507

1724

19

959

1769

22

1,469

1770

16

2,354

1771

21

1,307

Albert Hushnell ; 65.

Anieriean

History

3'ol(l by Contemporaries,

Albert Hnsbncll :

Americati

1 1 istory

Told by Contemporaries.

Vol. II, p. 7.S.

'■’Clianiiing, History of the Lhiitcd States, Vol. II, ]>p. 264-266.

.12

Square Rigged

V'essels

Schooners and Sloops

Total — (See above) 22 14 21

1769 14

1770 8

1771 15

8

8

6

No statistics have been found re Shipbuilding at Philadelphia again until 1793.

Between March 1 and June 29, 1793, tvvent\’-six vessels were built measuring 4,618 tons.

In the 18 months from January 1793 to June 30, 1794, the tonnage built amounted to 10,204 tons.

In 1795, 31 vessels were built; 1796, 22.

From March 1 to June 29, 1793 :

9 Ships. 2,462 tons; 9 Brigs, 1,542 tons; 3 Schooners, 344 tons ; 5 Sloops, 270 tons.

Philadelphia shiphuilding between 1783 and 1812 is acknowl- edged to have excelled any other south of New England and larger vessels were built in Philadelphia than in New England.

The oak and other woods along the Delaware were admirable in quality and abundant in quantity. The live oak was brought to Philadelphia from the South.

The shipyards stretched along the river front at Kensington and Southwark — as many as 12 or 15 were operating at one time. A master shipbuilders’ society flourished and not only were vessels built here for both foreign and domestic orders, but Samuel Bower, a Kensington Shipbuilder, was asked in 1800 to become the chief naval constructor of the Spanish Government and Samuel Hum- phreys received a similar offer from Russia.

The Rebecca Sims sailed from the Capes of the Delaware to London in 14 days in 1807. The IVoodrop Sims built in 1801 of over 500 tons. In the period 1800-1812 the cost of building vessels at Philadelphia varied from $20.00 to $36.00 a registered ton.

Samuel Bowers was horn at Southwark in 1760 and began shipbuilding at Kensington in 1789. In 1790 he received $2,940.67 for a ship and $1,288.66 for a brig — and did some $2,000 worth of repairs. In 1790 he did a business of about $15,000.

In 1796 he built the Samuel Smith of 705 tons for $24,000.

In 1795 he built the Indostan of 470 tons.

Built for the East Indian trade at $31.00 a ton.

Eor several years a ship for the China and East Indian trade was launched at Bower’s yard each year.

33

After 1816 he built several steamboats for use on the Dela- ware and other rivers. He once completed a brig of 200 tons in 6 weeks.

Vessels built

in Philadelphia (Partial List)

Tonnage

1781

7

1,120

1782

22

2,146

1783

40

4,477

1784

44

5,303

1785

20

2,412

1786

13

905

1787

16

1,644

The forty vessels built in Philadelphia in 1783 may be classi- fied as follows :

13 Ships & Barks 2,943 Tons

LS Brigs 1,243 Tons

4 Schooners , 91 Tons

8 Sloops 200 Tons

The largest were the ships Alliance 700 Tons

Thomson 300 Tons

Pigon 399 Tons

34

JOHN FRANKLIN

( Read at a meeting of the Society, November 25, 1935 )

Bv Dr. Julian P. Boyd

In the Harvard College Library is one of many hundreds of manuscripts thrown off by John Franklin during the course of his affliction with that incurable disease, cacoethes scrihendi. On its fly-leaf in the hand of Charles Eliot Norton is this inscription: “John Franklin, a natural leader of men.” Anyone accpiainted with the career of this remarkable Pennsylvanian, who come as near as anyone to dividing the State in two, must admit the truth of the inscription. The events that gave scope to his natural qualities of leadership were the most typical in American history : the receding frontier and the resultant clash of diverse sections. During the 18th century, when the Atlantic coastal plain was filling up, these forces produced bitter conflicts in which nearly every intercolonial boundary was brought into dispute. During the 19th century, when the lines of expansion ceased their North and South interplay and moved steadily westward, they produced the greatest of all sec- tional conflicts, the Civil War. If their clashing brought armed as well as legal conflict, these forces also produced some of the most rugged leaders in history. The Allens in Vermont and Colonel Sevier in Tennessee are revered because they established common- wealths. John Franklin’s grave is unmarked, for his dream of a free and independent state collapsed in ignominious failure, but Pennsylvania has cause to be proud of numbering him among her citizens. The principles he fought for were the same as those of the Allens and the Seviers ; indeed, they were the same as those expressed in the Declaration of Independence.

John Franklin was a youngster of four in Lyme, Connecticut, when his father invested $2.00 in a share in the Susquehannah Company, a venture which was intended to make good Connecti- cut’s charter claim to the whole of the 42nd parallel all the way to the Pacific Ocean. John Franklin's career might never have been molded by this apparently insignificant investment had not the Charter of Charles II to William Penn overlapped the one granted by the same monarch to Connecticut nineteen years earlier. That conflict of boundaries produced one of bitterest disputes in Ameri-

35

can history, and it shaped the destiny of young Franklin almost before he left the cradle.

Franklin’s father was not associating in this venture with turbulent and irresponsible men : some of the leading citizens of Connecticut believed that that colony had a valid right to the Northern half of the territory claimed by the Penns. They in- cluded such men as Silas Deane of Wethersfield, Roger Wolcott of East Windsor, Phineas Lyman of Suffield, Jonathan Trumbull of Lebanon, Eliphalet Dyer of Windham, and Roger Sherman and Ezra Stiles of New Flaven — all of them men whose names acquired honor and renown far beyond the borders of Connecticut. They never looked upon this venture as a mere dispute over bound- aries, but early dignified it with what they called “the Glory of this New World.” They sought as early as 1755 to obtain from the Crown permission to erect a new colony west of the Delaware for the “Defence of his Majesty’s Dominions in North America.” That, at least, was the object stated in public resolutions, although the Articles of Association of the Susquehannah Company, as drawn up at Windham, July 18, 1753, stated that the undertakers sought “To Spread Christianity as also to promote our own Tem- poral Interest.” Acting under these motives which admirably com- bined the spiritual and the economic, the leaders of the movement effeted Indian purchases in 1754 and 1755, and in 1760 a settlement was planted at Cushietunk or Coshecton'on the Delaware. But Thomas Penn had not been idle : he had seen his friend Lord Flalifax, president of the Board of Trade. He had also laid the matter of this invasion of the proprietors territory before William Pitt and Granville, lord president of the privy Council. He had also secured opinions in his favor from Attorney General Charles Pratt and Solicitor General Charles Yorke. With these legal sup- ])orts, he felt confident of the outcome. “As to their gaining a charter here.” he wrote Thomas Penn, “that can never he done. They have no friends, and if they had all you imagine, they could be of no use to them.” The Connecticut leaders indeed found out soon enough that they did not have the influence at court that the Penn [Proprietors had. They dis])atchcd Ifliplialet Dyer to London in 1764 in the. ho])c of obtaining a charter for a new colony in the heart of the territory claimed by the I’enns, hut D}^*!' soon found that he could be far more useful at home, despite the expensive clothes and the dress sword that he hoped would impress British

36

officials at state functions. The I’enns had likewise secured the support of the Secretary of State, Lord E^remont. Sir Jeffery Amherst, commander in chief of the British forces in America, and, probably most important of all, that greatest of all Indian agents, Sir William Johnson, Superintendent of Indian Affairs for the Northern Department.

But the legal and official field constituted only one of the bat- tlegrounds, and, from the standpoint of final results, not the most important. What was happening on the frontiers of Pennsylvania was of far more lasting consequence. The settlers at Coshecton had by this time built a large blockhouse equipped with swivel guns. The farmers of Northampton County began to look with covetous eyes at the prospect of owning land in fee simple under Connecticut laws, preferring this to the quit-rent tenure under a proprietary government. They also liked the democratic and in some respects even communistic method of land distribution car- ried on by the Connecticut people, and they bitterly opposed the favoritism of the Pennsylvania Land Office whereby the wealthy merchants and speculators of Philadelphia appropriated in large quantities the rich alluvial soils, leaving the settlers small tracts in the hills. The most important event affecting the outcome of the dispute, however, was one which took place when John Frank- lin was twenty years old. The Paxtang Boys under the leadership of Lazarus Stewart, those turbulent Scotch-Irish frontiersmen who had murdered the Conestoga Indians and who had terrified Phila- delphians by marching on the city in armed force, agreed to join hands with the Connecticut settlers in the Wyoming Valley. Early in 1770 they marched into the Valley and took possession in the name of the Susquehannah Company, driving the Pennsylvanians out of the rude log fort at the new settlement of Wilkes-Barre. Twice within the next year the Connecticut settlers and the Pax- tang Boys were driven out of the Valley, but late in the summer of 1771 they took permanent possession. In 1773 they drew up ar- ticles of government for the settlement, articles which might very well have established a new government under the Crown, but which did no more than regulate and establish local police powers. John Franklin was still in Connecticut, but it is interesting to speculate whether, if he had been present when these articles were drawn up, and if he had had the power and influence that were

37

his ten years later, Pennsylvania today would not be two States instead of one great commonwealth.

But the object of settlement had been achieved. By 1773 log houses were scattered up and down the Wyoming and Lackawanna Valleys, and the work of clearing the land and tilling the soil pro- ceeded without material interruption from the Pennsylvanians. By 1775 towns had been laid out on the West Branch of the Susque- hanna. thereby affecting the interests of such large landholders as William Maclay, James Tilghman, and Robert Morris. A sheriff’s posse comitatus, financed not by government but by private contributions from Philadelphia, was utilized in 1775 to drive out the Connecticut settlers. One company of mounted men marched against Coshecton, another of 500, with artillery, moved up the Susquehanna under the command of Sheriff Plunkett of Northumberland. But the expected battle turned out to be an ineffective skirmish, and the opening of the Revolution left the Connecticut people firmly entrenched. They were now living under Connecticut laws, for in 1774 the legislature of that colony had annexed Northern Pennsylvania to Litchfield County as the town of Westmoreland. The Litchfield Court of Quarter Sessions heard appeals from Westmoreland justices of the peace living in the Susquehanna wilderness and tavern licenses for dispensing liquors on the Wallenpaupack were granted by Connecticut magistrates two hundred miles away. In 1775 this enormous township, almost as large in territory as the whole colony of Connecticut, was erected into a county under the same name of Westmoreland. Represent- atives from Wyoming Valley sat in the legislature at New Haven and Hartford, and Sheriffs made election returns from Wyoming for the continuance in office of that old patriot, Jonathan Trum- bull. Indeed, it was said that this extension of the jirotective jur- isdiction of Connecticut over the new settlement was designed largely to secure votes for Trumbull. James Tilghman, who jiroh- ably got his information from Jared Ingersoll, wrote on Ajiril 3, 1774, that it was .said the ])rincipal use of the new town of West- moreland was “to gain a Number of votes for Mr. 4'rumbull. . . . at the next I'dection.” 4'he results lent credit to the rumor. On April 1 .some of the leaders of the Su.squehannah Comjiany in Con- necticut wrote to Zehulon ILitler, leader of the settlement at Wyoming, urging him to arouse the spirit of the settlers on elec- tion day. The ])ost.script carried the e.ssence of the letter, being in

.38

form a sort of circular of the party slate: it said “We no our Friends and we no oure Foes, and we can Tell Who we shall VTte for in the Uper Flouse, but we Dont want you Jentlemen to Vote as we Do with out it is your minds. Those Gentlemen that we have put here above are in the Nomination, and so we remane your Fast and Deare Friends and Hoping you Gintlemen will Re- mane so.” There can be no doubt that they did remain so. Samuel Gray reported to Governor Trumbull on April 30 that 500 freemen had voted at Wilkes-Barre on election day, “and your Honor & Colonel Dyer had Every Vote.” Two thousand settlers were on the lands by this time, and Connecticut newspapers were filled with descriptions of the immense fertility of the land, the rich timber resources and the healthful climate. Thus at the time that John Franklin left his home at Lyme to settle in Wyoming, twenty years of a bitter controversy had elapsed in which thousands of persons were involved, in which considerable blood had been shed, first in the Indian massacre of 1762, and later in the so-called First Pennamite War of 1769-1771, and in which the political conse- quences were so far-reaching as to make it a serious obstacle to the formation of the Union.

The years during the Revolution passed without disturbance to the Connecticut settlers in their enjoyment of these lands, ex- cept for the Wyoming Massacre of 1778. John Franklin left a long manuscript account of that horrible day and of its disastrous consequences, but he was not in the battle. As Captain of the Huntington or Tenth Company in the 24th Connecticut Regiment, he arrived at Forty Fort just as the battle was concluded and be- fore the massacre had begun. He did see actual service, however, for he was with Colonel Hartley's expedition the next year, and was also with Sullivan’s expedition in 1779. This training fitted him for the active leadership he was destined soon to assume.

Had the settlements at Wyoming and elsewhere on the Sus- quehannah Company’s tract resumed their peaceful ways at the end of the Revolution and continued under the jurisdiction of Connec- ticut. Franklin’s remarkable powers might have been spent in con- structive usefulness among his fellow citizens rather than in the dangerous and treasonable paths that he followed. But the contro- versy between Connecticut and Pennsylvania for rich lands in Northern Pennsylvania had resulted in the inclusion of a remark- able clause in the Articles of Confederation : for the first time in

39

history a tribunal for the settlement of war-provoking disputes between sovereign states had been set up. Under this Article IX Pennsylvania and Connecticut met through their representatives at Trenton in November and December, 1782, and went through the first great State trial between American States. Pennsylvania’s attorneys were James Wilson, Joseph Reed, and William Brad- ford ; those of Connecticut were Eliphalet Dyer, William Samuel Johnson, and Jesse Root. These six included two of the best law- yers in America: James Wilson and William Samuel Johnson. Their arguments were learned as well as lengthy, for the cause was momentous. John Hanson, President of the Confederation, had admonished the commissioners upon the solemnity of the occa- sion, warning them that “the peace of two States and consequently of the whole Union” depended upon a final and amicable settlement of the dispute. At the end of six weeks the court handed down a decree giving jurisdiction and preemption of the territory to Penn- sylvania. No reasons or written opinions were given : simply the bare decision was announced. This decision was the signal for the raising of the curtain on one of the most dramatic and least un- derstood episodes of American history.

\Vhat now was the status of the Susquehannah Company and its extensive tract of land in Northern Pennsylvania? What was the status of the thousands of people owning land and cultivated farms in seventeen townships extending along the Susquehanna from Nescopeck to Tioga? Were these lands that they had occu- pied and defended against Indian and British attack to he taken from them and granted to Pennsylvania claimants who, in most instances, had never seen them ? These were the questions that agitated the minds of the Connecticut settlers. There were some who wished to make an end of the bitter experiences they had gone through. Even such a veteran fighter as Zebulon Butler was will- ing to compromi.se. But from the very beginning John Eranklin took the jKJsition that the lands belonged to those who had cultivated them and fought for them, and nothing less than force could de- ])rive him of his own lands. He opposed everything that had the ap|)earance of tame submission, and he hurled defiance at Penn- .sylvania landowners as readily as he had fought against Great lUitain. His fighting spirit .soon arou.sed many of his neighbors, and he rapidly became the leader and the spokesman for the re- bellious .settlers.

40

The Pennsylvania legislature early in 1783 made a peaceful gesture toward the Connecticut settlers by passing a stay law against suits for ejectment. But this was only a gesture. Three commissioners were ap’pointed to inquire into the Connecticut claims. Urged on hy the Pennsylvania claimants, the commis- sioners proposed to the Connecticut people what they called a com- promise. More i)roperly it should be called a demand for uncon- ditional surrender of the lands claimed hy the Connecticut j^eople. The golden opportunity for bringing peace to this distressed re- gion was lost, and thousands of settlers passed on into Ohio and the Northwest where land titles were on a more solid foundation. The Commissioners plunged deeper into their error when they held secret elections for justices of the j>eace and maintained two com- panies of rangers at Wyoming, although there was no danger from the Indians. The legislature approved the report of the commis- sioners in the autumn of 1783, thus inaugurating twenty years of sufifering, bloodshed, and bitter controversy. The stay law against suits of ejectment was repealed, and one of the justices appointed was David Meade, an early Connecticut settler who had resided safely in Northumberland County during the Revolution, and who now appropriated as his own some 300 acres of the best land in Wilkes-Barre. Alexander Patterson, one of the newly-appointed justices of the peace and also agent for the Pennsylvania claimants, utilized the militia to evict Connecticut settlers. Many were thrown into jail without legal writ, and even widows and orphans of those slain in 1778 were driven from their homes. Colonel Zebulon Butler was arrested and held under bail of £5000, a circumstance which no doubt caused him to give up his claims to leadership in the community. But the desperation of the Connecticut settlers brought forth one whose natural qualities of leadership were easily recognized. On December 9, 1783, John Franklin presented to the Pennsylvania legislature the first of his many petitions in behalf of his fellow citizens.

Franklin was now thirty-four years of age, a man of tower- ing physique whose six feet four inches and wide-shouldered massive frame gave him a commanding presence in any company. His only known portrait, done at an advanced age when his gray- ing locks fell down about his shoulders, reveals a character with no weakness unless it was the weakness of excessive strength. Du- plicity, vacillation, dishonesty, insincerity, or ignoble motives are

41

given the lie by the countenance preserved for us by some un- known artist or itinerant limner. A noble forehead gave poise to the widely-spaced, intelligent eyes and the heavy, arched eyebrows. The aquiline nose, the thin, compressed lips so reminiscent of his Puritan ancestry, and the strength expressed in the firm line of chin and jaw but served to emphasize the outstanding features of the face, those calm, unflinching grey eyes. They are the eyes of a man who could, as John Franklin did more than once, look into the face of death without blanching. They are the eyes of a Con- necticut freeman, and they express the ideals of generations of men completely self-reliant who held to liberty and natural justice with a tenacity that could not be shaken with any threat. Not even his enemies ever questioned the courage and the incorruptibility that everyone acknowledged to be his. He was not an orator, but few speakers could argue so persuasively. He had a remarkable command of facts and even such lawyers as James Wilson and Jonathan Dickinson Sergeant did not know more about the legal foundations of the Connecticut claim than he did. Franklin was entirely self-taught, and though his prolific writings sometimes are inelegant in phraseology, they are never lacking in strength and forcefulness. Such was the man who could successfully bend to his purposes such men as Oliver Wolcott, Joel Barlow, and Ethan Allen.

The first petition that Franklin ]>resented resulted in a thor- ough investigation of the cruelties and injustices that were taking place at Wyoming. More than fifty depositions were taken, and at the end the legislative investigating committee found that the charges were fully and amply sustained. The report was recom- mitted, however, and Franklin found it necessary to attencl at Philadelphia during the session, where he enlisted the friendship and supjx)rt of such influential men as John Dickinson and Fred- erick A. Muhlenberg. Franklin likewise petitioned Congress for a new trial to adjudicate the ])rivate right of soil, going to Annapolis himself to deliver the document to the Connecticut delegates. But meanwhile the forces under Major I’atterson at Wyoming had driven one hundred and fifty families from their homes and sent them out on the old trail (jver the mountains by way of the Lack- awaxen to the Delaware River, h'or fourteen days this line of fugitives struggled through the wilderness and forded swollen streams. At least one old man, John Jenkins, died as a result of

42

the exjx^sure, and women and children suffered greatly because of the lack of food and shelter. This cruelty of Patterson resulted in the dismissal of the garrison from Wyoming, and he was in- dicted by the grand jury of Northumberland. Nevertheless, he defied the sheriff’s writs and remained in possession of the fort at Wilkes-Barre.

It was probably in the late spring of 1784 that Franklin was driven to the conclusion that the Connecticut settlers, in order to protect their land titles, would have to defend themselves and create another State. Connecticut could not longer be appealed to ; Pennsylvania was divided by financial and other troubles ; and the government of the Confederacy was fast sinking into impotency. Thus at the beginning of June he collected about thirty armed men on Wilkes-Barre mountain and fortified a place called fort Lillopee. On July 23rd his small force began the attack on Patterson’s forti- fication in the town of Wilkes-Barre. Franklin’s journal records in simple but dramatic words this opening of his fight for a new commonwealth, his open warfare against forces headed by a civil official of Pennsylvania : “marched in the morning to Wilkes-Barre, and the enemy began a heavy fire with their field piece, but none ventured from the fortification. The enemy had two four pounders, two swivels, and a wall piece guarded by a number of outworks and 200 men, at least three times our number. Mr. Franklin took possesion of the height east of the town and cut off communications with the grist mill. At 9 A.M. a small party was sent to attack the mill, guarded by a block house and twenty ruffians. At 10 A.M. Mr. Franklin sent a letter giving them two hours to evacuate the mill, which was done, and was then occupied by twelve of our old men. At 11 o’clock we took possession of two outhouses on the east of the town and within musket shot of the garrison in face of an incessant fire. . . .July 24 continued to ad- vance toward the block house directing our fire at the flash from their portholes and compelled them to cpiit their outposts on the east of the town. The night following began our intrenchments .... Sunday July 25th enemy began firing but our fire silenced their field pieces and compelled them to close their embrasures. . . , Tuesday July 27th. We discovered an intrenchment begun in the night to reach a well of water. We heard the working of a samp mortar denoting they were out of flour, Mr. Franklin was slightly wounded. ... Saturday, July 31 the enemy sent proposals for a

43

cessation of hostilities. . . .these were rejected. . . .Monday, August 2, quiet. At 11 P.M. Swift returned with his party and reported a battle near a block house at Locust Hill in the Great Swamp, twenty miles from Wyoming, and that he had killed and wounded several of the enemy and that only one of ours was slightly in- jured.”

On August 8 Colonel John Armstrong. Secretary of the Com- monwealth, arrived at Wilkes-Barre with 400 Northampton County Militia under the command of Colonel Craig. Franklin was asked to assemble his men under arms the next day and was assured that Patterson’s company had been disarmed and were prisoners. Ac- cordingly on Monday, wrote Franklin, “at 2 P.M. seventy-five of us paraded under arms. Colonel Armstrong formed the militia three hundred into a hollow square, into which we marched and grounded our arms, which were taken up and piled. Colonel Arm- strong then in a haughty manner said to Mr. Franklin, we must consider ourselves his prisoners. Our arms were then delivered to our enemies .... when the Counsel closed, Armstrong told us to prepare for a march.” We can imagine what Franklin said to the author of the notorious Newburgh Addresses for this breach of faith, hut his journal says with classic understatement: “Mr. Franklin reproached him for his conduct and for his' arming our enemies.”

Thus did Armstrong blast the Connecticut party’s hope of re- instatement in their titles to the land. The ]>arty under Swift that had fought the battle at Locust Hill were marched off to Easton to jail, where they promptly effected their escape. The others under Franklin were carried to Sunbury, where the friendly Sheriff Antis admitted them to hail. During August and Sc])tember the monotonous tale of this second Pennamitc-Yankee war contin- ued. Franklin and his ])arty fortified four small houses near the old Wyoming battlefield; here on October 18 they were attacked by 150 of Patterson’s men, and h'ranklin’s intimate friend William Jackson was killed. Seizing the rifle wet with the blood of his devoted friend, Franklin is said to have raised it above his head and there in the ])resence of his followers to have sworn a solemn oath never to lay down his arms until death should arrest his hand or Armstrong he expelled from Wyoming, the people restored to their possessions, and guaranteed a legal trial. By November 27 the I’ennamite forces had evacuated and the Connecticut people

44

had been reinstated. Meanwhile, the Connecticut men indicted at Snnbnry were acquitted and the charges of treason lodged against Franklin and forty of his followers was ignored. Thus nearly two years of fruitless and sometimes bloody struggle had done nothing to settle the dithcnlt questions involved, and instead had made any immediate settlement impossible by driving Frank- lin to the fixed determination to set up a new State. During 1785 and 1786 Wyoming was free of the turmoil of the i)receding two years, yet it was during this period that Franklin organized his following and laid his plans. Fte was now convinced, he said, that “our only recourse was in arms.”

He deliberately embarked, therefore, on a course that was, to say the least, treasonable. Without means save a farm in Hunting- ton township, without influence or connections, this young man of thirty-five set out first to gain control of the old Susquehannah Company. This done, he could hold out to prospective settlers the lure of cheap and fertile land. He could settle hundreds of sympa- thetic New England men on the lands of the upper Susquehannah, and in the end perhaps defy the greatest of the American States. IMost of the winter and spring of 1784-1785 Franklin spent in Con- necticut, talking at the taverns, the meeting houses, the homes of friends and old members of the Company, setting forth the long tale of suffering of the Connecticut settlers at Wyoming. First to Wind- ham and Lebanon, to seek out such men as Dyer and Trumbull, then to Colchester and down to Lyme, back to Hartford and Wind- sor, Franklin went, and finally to Farmington to consult his old friend, William Judd. Judd it was whom Franklin induced to draft a constitution for the new State. Then back to Wyoming to see that there was no weakening among the settlers there, and early in the spring he was in Connecticut again, bringing influences to bear to enlist the support of Ethan Allen and his brother Ira, men who had already created a State on the New Hampshire grants. Some- times he traveled by horse, but generally on foot. Wherever a shareholder might be, however remote his farm among the snow- capped hills in Connecticut, Franklin sought him out and plead his cause tirelessly. In May he was on the Susquehanna again, and July found him back in Connecticut for the third time in almost as many months.

His ceaseless agitation was now beginning to bear fruit. On July 13 the Susquehannah Company met at Hartford, and Frank-

45

lin held the power in his own hands. It was he who dictated the resolution that amounted to the drafting of a small army of men who would fight for land for themselves and their families. On that day it was voted “That every able bodied and effective man approved by any of the Company’s Committee, not being a pro- prietor, and that will repair to Wyoming, submit himself to the orders of the Company and their committee at that place, shall be- come a half-share proprietor in said company ... .provided he remains for the space of three years. . . .and arrive there by the first day of October next.” The committee, which henceforth be- came the directing force of the Company, was headed by Franklin, and the headquarters of the Company were now transferred to the banks of the Susquehanna. Franklin also realized the need of money for arms and ammunition, and he secured a vote to sell six hundred whole shares in the Company.

Franklin at once embarked upon a campaign to enlist the half- share recruits and to sell the 600 whole shares. He was so success- ful that most of the region embraced in the present counties of Susquehanna, Bradford, and Wyoming was settled by Connecticut yeomen. By November he was able to call together a meeting of some four hundred of these men. At this meeting a regiment was formed, and Franklin was elected colonel. But the most important step was the formation of a system of government. “A form of government,” wrote Franklin, “was also estal:)lished by the author- ity of the people November 25, 1785, to remain in force until law should be established on constitutional principles. A committee of directors was also appointed to regulate the affairs of the settle- ment agreeable to the form of government adopted and upwards of four hundred subscribed their names to siq^port the committee or directors in the execution of the ini])ortant trust imposed in them.” Franklin now found himself head of the military and the civil administration of his settlement, and he controlled the business affairs of the Susquehannah Com])any. The prospects for the new State looked ])romising, and never more .so than in April, 1786, when one of the boldest spirits of the Revolution, the Hero Ticonderoga, Ethan Allen, ap|)eared at Wyoming dressed in regi- mentals and ])ledged his assistance to the Connecticut settlers.

A month later the Continental Congress accepted the Connecti- cut cession of her western lands, and both Franklin and Allen looked upon this as favorable to their enterprise. It was at this

46

period that William Judd is said to have drafted a constitution for the New State, and in September Ethan Allen issued a stirring broadside calling upon the Connecticut settlers to unite in the new cause. After offering to submit to the laws of Pennsylvania if the lands were confirmed to the Connecticut settlers, the address con- cluded with the statement that the ultimate end of law was to secure life, liberty, and property. When law was degenerated in administration and subverted to meet the ends of cruel men and to eject from their lands the yeomanry who support mankind : when government no longer protected the lives and property of its subjects, then the subjects were thrown into a state of nature, and they not only owe no allegiance to such a government, but have a just and natural right to make a bold and manly resistance. There can be no doubt of the origin of these phrases : they come straight from the Declaration of Independence. Allen concluded his broad- side with characteristic phrase, exhorting the Connecticut settlers to choose between slavery and poverty or liberty and property.

Thousands of clearings now appeared along the Tunkhan- nock and the Wyalusing, and the fertile meadows of Claverack and Ulster invited the stream of determined emigrants from the East. Franklin’s regiment of six hundred men, the opening of stores of arms and ammunition at Tioga Point, and the promise of aid from the Green Mountain Boys awakened the Pennsylvania authorities to the desparate situation that the bungling Patterson and Armstrong had created. The people living on the West Branch of the Susquehanna signified their desire to join in with Franklin, and land disputes in western New York led such men as Caleb Benton and Dr. Joseph Hamilton of New York to lend their assistance.

The leading Pennsylvania landholders, therefore, saw that something had to be done. Tench Coxe and James Wilson, two of the most farsighted among the Pennsylvania claimants, per- ceived that the older settlers around Wilkes-Barre, and still under the leadership of Zebulon Butler, were willing to compromise. The radical element under Franklin was centered around Tioga Point. They thought, therefore, the erection of a new county which would give the Wyoming settlers some administration of their affairs, would bring matters to a close and defeat the dismemberment of the State. Accordingly a statute was passed creating the county of Luzerne, and in January, 1787, Timothy Pickering was sent to

47

Wilkes-Barre to organize the county government. A wiser choice could not have been made. Pickering was himself a New Englander, a graduate of Harvard who had held important posts during the Revolution and who served as Secretary of State under Washing- ton and Adams. He was discreet and won the confidence of the Wyoming people by purchasing a home and casting his lot with them. Franklin did all he could to oppose the election of members of the legislature from the new county, but in this he was unsuc- cessful as he himself was elected. But he could not be bribed by office to desert his cause, and refused to serve. Franklin was never more active than during the winter and spring of 1786-1787, and it was at this time that his bold scheme came nearest to realization. Pickering realized that something had to be done: the county was organized, but the people, or at least a majority of the most active people, were with Franklin. He therefore induced Chief Justice McKean to issue a warrant in secret charging Franklin with treason. This was placed in the hands of four daring men, former soldiers, who were secreted at Wilkes-Barre hy Pickering. Late in September, 1787, Franklin was at Salem and Huntington, as Pick- ering says, “])reparing his adherents for the explosion.” Three or four days later he came to Wilkes-Barre and while standing on the river bank was seized. Evidently the four men found their hands full, for it was necessary to send for assistance to Pickering. “Just as 1 met them,” wrote Pickering, “Franklin threw himself ofF from his horse and renewed his struggle with them. His hair was dishevelled and face bloody from ])receding efforts. 1 told the gentlemen they would never carry him off unless his feet were tied under his horse’s belly. I sent for a cord. The gentlemen re- mounted him and my servant tied his feet. Tlie one taking his bridle, another following hehind, and the others riding one on each side, they whipped up his horse and were soon beyond the reach of his friends. 1 would have avoided this stej) if T had not believed the welfare of the good ])cople of the county depended on seizing the person of that daring man.” This forcible seizure occurred rictober 2, 1787, and that night Pickering, fearing violent retali- ation, slipped out of his home and made his way to Philadel])hia. Franklin was confined in jail here, heavily hound in irons, and denied the privilege of communicating with his friends. He lacked clothes and bedclothing, and for nearly two years he was confined without being brought to trial. In November, 1788, he was carried

48

to Wilkes-Barre and arraigned before Chief Justice McKean, charged with high treason in endeavoring to subvert the govern- ment and to erect a new and independent state. He was repre- sented by George Clymer and Charles Biddle, two of the States most eminent lawyers. But his case was continued and he was re- turned to the prison in Philadelphia. When at last he was released in the summer of 1789, the dream of a new commonwealth had been blasted forever.

Ethan Allen was dead. Timothy Pickering returned to Salem. Oliver Wolcott became a distinguished Federalist leader and Sec- retary of the Treasury. Many of Franklin’s lieutenants had ab- sconded to New York, and he himself returned to Athens where he resumed life as a farmer. The State of Pennsylvania had passed a law confirming titles to those Connecticut settlers who had inhabited their lands prior to the Trenton decree, and though the final settle- ment was not begun until 1799 and did not end until well into the 19th century, the end of Franklin’s dream came on that October day in 1787. Forty years later a tall figure with flowing white hair might have been seen at a window overlooking the beautiful Susquehanna at Tioga Point, forever scribbling at his desk. All that remained of his vision of empire, a vision which came dangerously close to being realized solely through his phenomenal efforts, was a stack of yellowing manuscript volumes of the records of the Susque- hannah Company. On the blank pages of these volumes the aged John Franklin, indomitable to the last, wrote long letters to the local newspapers extolling the virtues of another rugged frontier character, Andrew Jackson. He died in 1831 and his grave lies not in the place he had planned for the Capital of a new state, but in one of the most beautiful valleys of this great and beautiful Commonwealth.

49

COLONIAL FRANKFORD (Read at a meeting of the Society, March 22, 1937)

By Horace W. Castor

Frankford is situated in the great Northeast — the fastest growing section of Philadelphia — surrounded by such old settle- ments as Kensington, Aramingo, Harrogate, Bridesburg, White- hall, Wissinoining, Tacony, Holmesburg, Byberry, Bustleton, Somerton, Fox Chase, Lawndale, Rowlandville, Cheltenham, Cedar Grove, Crescentville and Olney.

Frankford in its early da}^s was a beautiful rural section, with rolling country, clear running streams, wooded sections of many varieties of native trees ; high in location and rich in soil ; all of which induced many to possess themselves of plantations and to build houses of goodly proportions and pleasing colonial design.

It is true the Swedes and Dutch were here before William Penn’s time. The old grist mill along Frankford Creek was in operation when Penn bought the mill from the early Swedes, and it continued to su]>ply dour for thrifty housewives during and after the Revolutionary War.

Henry Waddy, a milliner of Holborn, in the Parish of St. Andrews, London, England, was among the first settlers in Frankford. He came to seek that quietness and freedom of worship as a member of the Society of Friends which was denied him in England. He obtained from William Penn a grant of about 750 acres of land in the new Province of Penn. In 1682 he arrived and secured and located about 550 acres in Oxford Township, Philadel])hia. d'his vast holding covered a great por- tion of what is now Erankford, and ])art of the Thirty-fifth Ward.

Henry Waddy (and I know of no street named for him or monument erected to his memory) was one of the members of the First Grand Jury of the First Court held at Philadelphia, January 1683. Among the first duties of this Grand Jury was the opening of roads and the building of bridges and ferries.

I laving given consideration to such re(|uirements in the newly-founded Philadel])hia, their next stej) was to make good and proper road communications to outlying sections, — and so we find the first Grand Jury recommending improvements for

50

Shackaniaxon (now Kensington), and also that the King's Road from Schnlkill (Schuylkill) through Philadelphia to Neshaminy Creek be laid out and made passable for horses and carts, with consideration for locating ferries on the Schuylkill and Neshaminy Creek, and bridges for Taiikanney (Frankford Creek) and at Gunner Rambo’s (afterwards known as Gunner’s Run).

The King’s Road sometimes called the Great Road, the New York Road through Frankford was the connecting link be- tween New York and Philadelphia, and was in use as early as 1677. It was the first legally surveyed road in Penn’s new settle-

Still Standing on the Poquessing Creek at Torresdale

From the original pen and ink sketch by Wm. J. Glackens, made on the scene in 1894.

ment, starting from Front and Vine Streets, through Frankford, to a white oak sapling at Parson’s Mill on Tacony Creek, to Po- qnessing Creek, where the fine old colonial “Red Lion Inn” now stands, and around which Washington’s Army camped over night on its way to Yorktown in 1781.

Henry Waddy was a member of the Oxford Monthly Meet- ing of Friends. One of his sons (John), died on the 18th of Twelfth Month, 1683, and was the first person to be buried in the Friends Burial Ground on Wain Street, Frankford. The Meeting House and Burial Grounds are still in existence. The first Meeting House was of logs. The Meeting House now stand-

51

ing was erected in 1775. I used to worship there with my grand- mother.

There are several versions as to how Frank ford received its name. It was first known as “Taconick”, then “Oxford”. Ten men from Frankfort-on-Main, Germany, purchased 25,000 acres from Penn and established Germantown. Frankford Greek flow- ing into the Delaware River, gave access to Germantown by the use of shallow sloops. A branch of Frankford Creek — the Wingo- hocking — had its rise in the land of the Frankford Company, and thus it seems that the name of Frankford originated.

Arrow-heads have been found along Frankford Creek. Wat- son’s Annals tells of Christopher Kuhn in 1819, digging a cellar on Kinsey and Hilles’ tan-yard, locating and uncovering a pot of old coins, hidden perha])S, by pirates. The glazed pot contained one hundred pieces of various sizes and shapes of silver coin, many of which were cut pieces of the size which would remain from cutting quarters and half dollars into sections of four pieces each. He observed dates on some as old as three hundred vears. One ])iece was as large as a crown and was square. Two pieces had a tree on one side and were marked “Massachusetts”.

In 1756 the Germans began to purchase land in and around Frankford, Rudolph Nefif among the first.

John George Castor, of Basle, Switzerland, arrived in l^hila- delj)hia in 1736. He went to Germantown to live, and in 1762 he ])urchased land, consisting of 202 acres, in Oxford Townshi]) (in which was Frankford), on the “10th of March in the Third ^'ear of the reign of our Sovereign Lord George the Third over Great Britain. France and Ireland.” Castor Road was afterwards cut through his ]>roperty.

About 1740 the Wains, Henry Drinker (you know the name better from Iflizaheth Drinker’s Diary). Edwards Stiles, Samuel Sansom, C harles Willing and Andrew .Soz also ])urchased ground here. Dr. Benjamin Rush owned ground from hh*ankford Creek to Oxford Pike, just below the ()xford Church.

The first census of Oxford Township in 1790, showed a |)oj)ulation of one hundred and seventy-five (175) head of fam- ilies. In 1800, at the time of the incorporation of h'rankford as a Borough, there were about one thousand ( 1000) inhabitants.

Back in Penn’s time the City of Philadelphia extended north

52

as far as Vine Street and contained about two square miles, as compared with 129 square miles today; and the great Northeast — of which Frankford is now the important and vital part (a city in itself) — is measured hy 88 square miles out of this 129 square miles, with a population of over three-eighths of the total of the entire city.

The Revolutionary War of 1776 gave to Frankford its legendary history. The yellow fever of 1793 in Philadel])hia was a blessing in disguise to Frankford, for many left Philadelphia to escape the dreaded disease and became permanently located in Frankford. The great industrial advancement of Frankford between 1840 and 1850 increased its population one hundred and thirty percent (IdO^t).

The horse cars patented and made by Thomas Castor in Frankford in 1858 were the first of their kind to run over steel rails — thus introducing to Frankford comfort of travel with rapid transit as compared with the stage coach, and preceded by one year the first Pullman car in the United States, which carried four passengers in wooden bunks and which were heated with wood burning stoves. The opening of the present elevated train service in 1922 also contributed to the present greatness of Frank- ford.

Some day someone will write an historical novel about this old King’s Highway — romancing in and around Frankford — for here is a wealth of historical material which has never been touched by any novelist.

Alas, the name of “King’s Highway’’ is no more. It is known to this generation as “Frankford Avenue’’, but to old Frankford- ians it is still “Main Street”.

The automobiles, the trolleys and the elevated of these mod- ern times thunder, in noisy confusion, their utter disdain and disrespect for the fine old traditions of the King’s Highway. Up and down this King’s Highway, through Frankford. traveled William Penn to his manor, Pennsbury, and the delegates from New England and New York to the Continental Congress — the King’s troops in all their glamor, and the somber Continental sol- diers with their peerless leaders. Washington and LaFayette.

Here passed the express rider on an April day in 1775, in- forming Frankford’s startled residents of the Battle of Lexington — five days after the battle. Over this King’s Highway traveled

53

soldiers of the War of 1812, the Mexican War, the Civil War, and twice the ex-King of Spain, Joseph Bonaparte. Great droves of cattle were also driven from Ohio to New York over this historic highway. Dolly Madison was a frequent traveler to Frank ford visiting Elizabeth Drinker.

What material there is for a novelist in the story of Captain Allen McLane — a most daring officer of the Continental Army. A spring day in 1778, on the King’s Highway, at “The Rocks” — then the outskirts of Frankford.

On this spring day in ’78 the Colonel with a small Company, while on their way to join Captain Craig, surprised by an am- buscade of British soldiers — put spurs to their horses, and dis- charging their pistols, made their escape in the woods — so they thought — but in coming out into the open again they discovered a troop of British soldiers. With escape apparently cut off. Cap- tain McLane advanced as if to surrender. Suprising the British by this maneuver, he suddenly turned to the road leading to Oxford Church (this Church is still in use), in an endeavor to make his escape. Two of the British troopers were sent in pursuit and overtook the Captain. The British, feeling sure of their prisoner, sheathed their swords, and the Captain, taking advan- tage of their being off-guard, fired his pistol, shooting one of the troopers, and using the empty pistol, knocked the other trooper from his mount. Still pursued by the rest of the British troop, the Captain however, made his escape into the swamp near Shoe- maker’s Mill at Ogontz.

This thrilling action took place where now the Frankford Elevated has its terminus, and where Cedar Hill and East Cedar Hill Cemeteries are located.

Cedar Hill Cemetery is the peaceful resting place of many Old Frankfordians. In one lot is a Surveyor’s stone marker, placed there by Captain Thomas Holme, William Fenn’s surveyor. Captain Holme is buried in the Crispin Pmrial Ground, not far from Frankford, and reached by the east branch of the Roosevelt Boulevard, from Fennypack Circle.

Captain Holme preceded I’enn here, and laid out three dif- ferent sections for Fenn’s apjn'oval for the new city. (One at Chester). On I’enn’s arrival, he ins])ected the site along the Delaware near the pre.sent Holmeshurg, and near I’ennshury, but due to the ‘‘Hens and Chickens” a formidable foundation of rocks

54

in the river, near the shore, interfering with deep water navigation, this site was not chosen.

Holmes had however surveyed a great “High Street” which was to rnn from the Delaware River to the Susquehanna River. Susquehanna Road, in north east Philadelphia, is a part of the original survey.

When General LaFayette was wounded at the Brandywine, at Chadd’s Ford, September 11, 1777, he was brought to Phila- delphia from Chester by boat and cared for in the Indian Queen Tavern. P'rom Philadelphia he was conveyed by boat to Bristol, passing the month of Frankford Creek and viewing rural Frank- ford from that point; passing also Point-no-Point just below Bridesbnrg. He was conveyed from Bristol by carriage; spent the night at Langhorne ; passed through Newtown and arrived in Bethlehem, where this twenty-year old French Nobleman, now a Major-General, was nursed back to health.

In contrast with his passing by Frankford on his way up the Delaware, as a wounded officer, was General LaFayette’s tri- umphal last visit in 1824. He arrived in New York on August 14th, of that year, on the packet “Cadmus”, to make his last visit to the various parts of the country, and to receive honor and acclaim from his admirers. A model of the “Cadmus”, made by Captain John Allen of Frankford, is at the Frankford Historical Society.

Accorded royal receptions en route from New York to Phila- delphia, he arrived at Frankford over the King’s Highway.

When I was a boy I heard old Frankfordians relate incidents about LaFayette’s visit of 1824 to Frankford, and of the singing of the “Star Spangled Banner” by the young ladies on the plat- form of the arch under which LaFayette passed. One of these old Frankfordians, Charles E. Deal, whom I remember, wrote an interesting account of this memorable visit. I quote in part ;

“The nation’s guest arrived at Bristol on September 27,

1824, where he spent a part of the day and night. On the morning of the 28th, he started from Bristol for Phila- delphia, escorted by a detachment of the City Troop under command of Captain Linford Lardner and a guard from the Frankford Artillery Company, with its cannon, and several visiting companies of mounted volunteers.

55

and a numerous cavalcade (mostly farmers), to the rendezvous of the Second Brigade of Pennsylvania Vol- unteers and the other companies of visiting soldiers. This was on the Frankford and Bristol Turnpike at the General Wayne Tavern, above Holmesbnrg, where the other visiting companies of volunteers which had camped the night before on Rush’s Field, and where the Second Brigade of Pennsylvania Volunteers joined them. Here all the military came under the command of General Samuel Castor.

“LaFayette was in an open carriage drawn by six cream-colored horses with postilions, and he frequently stood up and bowed to the spectators as he passed. Jacob Foulkrod, who was wounded at the Battle of German- town, Henry Magg, Charles Ristine and his son, Joseph Ristine, who served in the Revolutionary War, were in an open carriage, and in another were the Burgesses.

‘Whe chief incident in Frankford was the arch across the Main Street opposite the residence of General Isaac Worrel, No. 4v333 Frankford Avenue. There was a stage or platform over the arch on which there were a number of young girls who sang as the procession passed. This part of the program was under the direc- tion of Jesse Y. Castor. Mrs. Sarah Pratt, nee Durns, and her sisters Angeline and Cordelia Durns, Hannah and Louisa Duffield, daughters of Col. Thomas W. Duf- field, Sarah Dungan, Mary Ann Bodine, Elizabeth Comly, Ellen Comly, Hannah Thomas, Laura Coats, Sarah Retzer, Sarah Thomas and Mary Thomas, daugh- ter and grand-daughter of Squire Daniel Thomas. I^diza- heth Haines, the Misses Coon, daughter of Jacob and Christo])her Coon, Miss Phili])S, grand-daughter of Henry Magg, who was a lieutenant in the Maryland line of the Revolutionary War; the Misses l>auhert, Eliza Castor. Sarah Castor, the Misses McVaugh, Mary Ann T.amh, and others were there.

“General hsaac Worrel was sick at the time, and as the ]>rocession ])as.sed. was helped to the window and General LaT^'ayette bowed to him.

“The older ])ersons who witnessed the parade

56

through the City in 1788, in honor of the ratification of the Constitution of the United States, said tlie LaFayette parade was larger than the parade on that occasion.

“Except those who had conscientious scruples against such vanities, the Frankford people illuminated their houses that night and many pounds of tallow candles were burned and a great many people kept busy snuffing them. In the evening there was a hall at Samuel Wakeling’s ( Allengrove) , which some of the notable people of Frankford attended.”

The gathering of the leading delegates to the Continental Congress, held in Frankford on August 29, 1774, was a mo- mentous one, second only in importance to the Assembly for the signing of the Declaration of Independence. At least, that is how I view it.

Pennsylvanias were mostly Quakers and loyal British sub- jects. With this in mind, many of the delegates to the Continental Congress wanted no interference from that source which might cause delay in effecting a. Declaration of Independence. Especially was this true of firey Samuel Adams of Massachusetts.

He had kept Boston afire with his desire for independence from England since 1768. This attitude on his part was induced by the action of the British soldiers, in Boston, in an endeavor to force the collection of dues, or taxes, particularly on a ship- load of smuggled Madeira belonging to his friend, John Hancock; then again by the riot and massacre in 1770, starting over a boy's ragging of an officer of the English Horse Guards, for not paying his barber’s bill. Adams was further irritated by the East India Company trying to undersell the tea used by the Colonies, which mostly was smuggled from Holland; finally climaxing in the Boston Tea Party.

So Samuel Adams, burning with his desire to break away from England, met, on this August day in Frankford, with other active Sons of Liberty, such as Dr. Benjamin Rush, Thomas Mif- flin, Thomas McKean, John Rutledge, John Baird, Folsom Sul- livan, John Adams, Thomas Cushing, James Bowdoin, and Robert Treat Paine. This serious body of men held a caucus in

57

Frank ford and determined on certain procedures to expedite the signing of the Declaration of Independence.

The great significance and importance of this meeting in Frankford is attested by a letter written by John Adams, former President of the United States, in 1822, to Colonel Timothy Pickering, as follows :

“This conversation and the principles, facts and mo- tives suggested in it have given color, complexion and character to the whole policy of the United States from that day to this. Without it, Mr. Washington would never have commanded our armies, nor Mr. Jefferson been the author of the Declaration of Indej>endence ; nor Mr. Richard Henry Lee the mover of it ; nor IMr. Chase the mover of foreign connections. If 1 have ever had cause to repent of any part of the policy, that repent- ance ever has been, and ever will be, unavailing. I had forgot to say, nor had J\Ir. Johnson ever been the no- minator of Washington for General. You inquire why so young a man as Mr. Jefferson was placed at the head of the Committee for ])reparing a Declaration of Inde- pendence? I answer — It was the Frankford advice to place Virginia at the head of everything. Mr. Richard Henry Lee might be gone to Virginia to his sick family for aught I know, hut that was not the reason of Mr. Jefferson’s appointment.”

There was plenty of war activity up and down the King’s Highway on the part of both armies. Frankford was always hearing the martial strains of music, the tramp of men and horses. It was dis])uted ground. Companies were enlisted and officered from the young men of Frankford and the surrounding country.

There was Captain Rudolph Neff’s Flying Camp in 1776; the Militia of Oxford Township with its two companies in the Battalion of Col. Benjamin McVeagh of Frankford; the nearby Bucks County Militia, in which Jacob Castor was Lieutenant of the Seventh Company.

In December 1777, Sir William Ifrskine with a large force marched up Frankford Avenue for forage and plunder, as far as Bucks County. The Queen’s Rangers were very active robbing and plundering and taking pri.soners. A patrol of cavalry under

58

Major Gwyn, lighting it out toward Bristol, beat a hurried re- treat, and were pursued hy cavalry under Count Pulaski.

It was a mean piece of business, and not at all gallant, when British Light Horse took from Mrs. Edward Stiles a horse and chaise at the Port Royal Plantation, and compelled her to con- tine her journey on foot to the city, on that cold day in December, 1777.

I have already told you about Captain Allen McLane at “The Rocks.” There were many other incidents of fighting and war activities. There was the fight around the “Jolly Post,” disastrous to the raw Colonial soldiers, with the countersign “Richmond” chalked in their hats.

Most of the gunpowder for the Colonial Army was made on Powder Mill Lane, on Frankford Creek, to the west of Frank- ford.

Some patriots in New England thought another gunpowder factory should be established in New England, so to that end, one Paul Revere, he of the Midnight Ride fame, was delegated to visit Frankford, call on Captain Oswald Eve and George Loesch, owners of the Mill, and learn from them their secret of manufacture. Presenting his credentials he was refused, but on solicitation was permitted to go through the factory and watch the different processes of manufacture. This seems to have been sufficient for the astute Paul, and so he went away with the desired information.

Eve and Loesch were working under an agreement with Congress, which imported and supplied the nitre to them. Con- gress paying them $8.00 per hundredweight for the powder.

Evil days befell Captain Eve. He was tried and found guilty of high treason and on July 6, 1778, his two hundred and two acres, on the west side of Frankford, on which was the Powder Mill, and his real and personal estate were confiscated by the Commonwealth.

Paul Revere was not the only man of renown to visit Frank- ford on the business of powder making. There was also a French- man, who was interested in the purchase of the powder mill. He felt that his formula was an improvement over that then in use. He made an offer of purchase, hut was refused. He also visited likely places through New Jersey, like the spot on the Musconet- cong, opposite Riegelsville. Had this Frenchman, E. I. du Pont,

59

been successful in his Frankford purchase, I wonder if now, Frankford on the Frankford Creek, instead of Wilmington on the Christiana Creek, would not have been the great manufactur- ing home of the present du Pont Company with its $721,000,000 of assets?

There was another gunpowder mill, which was owned by Captain Stephen Decatur. It was located on the northwest side of Powder Mill Lane, southwest of Frankford Creek. It was destroyed by an explosion on June 12, 1806. The minutes of the Washington Fire Company, No. 1, (instituted in Frankford, January 1st, 1793) also records the fact that a bill was presented to Stephen Decatur, a fellow member, on October 4, 1803, for one dollar, for a horse to draw the engine to Captain Decatur’s on a late alarm of fire. (I have the original fire horn of the Washington Fire Co. 1793.)

Captain Stephen Decatur lived in Frankford, he commanded merchant ships for Gurney & Smith. His son. Commodore Decatur, who lost his life at the age of forty-one, in a duel with Commodore Barron, was made famous by his successful exploits in the war of 1812, by his successes against Tripoli and Algiers, and in taming the Barbary rulers.

The King’s Highway — Frankford Avenue — Main Street, was again to witness an historical event which I believe justifies my statement that no other highway was ever' travelled by so many distinguished i)ersonages of the Revolutionary War, nor any sec- tion of the Colonies was so active for its size, as was this little settlement of Frankford.

It was in the late summer of 1781 that General Washington with his staff and army marched through Frankford on his way from New York to Yorktown to ca])ture Cornwallis. A stop was made at the old Historic “Jolly Post”. I remember when this march of 1781 was commemorated by General Winfield S. Han- cock and the United States Regular Army one hundred years later, passing over the .same route in 1881 as did Washington and his army in 1781.

What a day that was for h’rankford when, on December 8, 1783, the President of the State, John Dickinson, the financier, Robert Morris, Generals ,St. Clare and Hand, the Philadelphia d'roop of Horse, and a number of citizens met his F.xcellency, George Washington, at b^rankford and e.scorted him to I’hila-

60

delphia, while he was enroute to Annapolis to be “translated into a private citizen.”

Then again, when President Adams passed through Frank- ford at the time of his return to Philadel])hia in November 1797 ; I quote from the Porcupine Gazette, of November 11, 1797 —

“Yesterday, about two o’clock in the afternoon, the Presi- dent of the United States (John Adams) arrived in town, after an absence of between three and four months. He was met at Frankford and escorted to town by three Volunteer Troops of Horse of this city, commanded by Captains Dunlap, Singer and Morrell, and the County Troup commanded by Captain Forrest. On alighting from his carriage, he was welcomed by the huzzas of a crowd of citizens, assembled on the occasion, and the Heads of Departments immediately waited upon him with their con- gratulations on his safe return to the Seat of Government.”

Recently I gave to the Frankford Historical Society a copy of the newspaper Aurora of June 25 and June 27, 1808, giving quite a detailed account of a sham-battle on June 22, 1808, known as the “Battle of Point-on-Point,” (near the mouth of Frankford Creek) .

A flotilla of seventy-twm boats brought troops up the Dela- ware to Frankford Creek, where they were to land under fire from the opposing force. The headquarters for this military fete was in Castor’s Woods. The Lieutenant-Colonel and Com- mandant— Jonas Simonds — gave particular praise to the officers of his staff. Acting Adj-General, G. Bartram, and Majors Smiley and Shull. The Lieutenant-Colonel in his report wrote further :

“The maneuvers were executed perfectly to the Com- mandant’s satisfaction, and it affords him pleasure in common with every man who possesses the feeling of an American, to see in this comparatively small force the foundation of discipline and a perfection in the applica- tion of the new tactics that must be productive of the greatest benefit to our country should we be forced into war.”

The scope and design of the military maneuver was to bring into as close a resemblance of real action as practicable, that of an invading enemy, and the other a defending army — using the new

61

Napoleon Tactics. The invading army, by flotilla from the city to Frankford Creek was described in the Aurora as follows:

“The picture which the flotilla exhibited was too inter- esting to be described without the aid of a pencil. The river from the lowest part of the City and during the whole course of about eight miles, appeared most animating, the numerous barges and boats with their variegated pendant streamers and flags, the groups of beauty which surrounded the flotilla, the cheering music of the excellent band of Captain Fotterall’s Corps, the cheerful good nature of the honest tars, and the cordial- ity which prevailed between them and their fellow- citizens * * * ^11 presented such pleasing spectacle as this City has not witnessed since its evacuation by the British under General Sir H. Clinton.”

Now let us look at some of the old buildings for additional inspiration for our novelist, and a little into the history of the various owners.

As you descend today the steps of the Frankford “L” to the sidewalks at Orthodox Street, (in Colonial Days, Smith’s Lane), at the northwest corner of Frankford Avenue and Orthodox Street, pause a moment, please, for you are now on “holy ground”. You may not want to take your shoes from oflf your feet, but you can at least take your mind from off the mundane j)resent and go back with me to “Old Colonial Frankford.”

It is regrettable that the intimate history of old Frankford is not taught in any of the magnificent schools of Frankford, and is as unknown to most of the younger generation (and teachers, too) as is the music of the pump handle and a drink of good, old- fa.shioned, cold, S])arkling pump water, out of the old iron dipi^er.

Just a few doors from where we are standing at the Ortho- dox Street corner, on the west side of Frankford Avenue, and at the .second floor level of a modern store (and more’s the pity it is not down at the eye level), one reads on a bronze tablet, erected by the Frankford Historical Society:

“F.rected by the people of Frankford to mark the site of The Old jolly Lost, a Revolutionary Inn. Hallowed by memories of Washington, LaFayette and other

62

JOLLY POST INN (Demolished 1911) On the King’s Highway, Frankford

Patriots. Headquarters of Captain Allen McLane’s Dra- goons. The scene of more skirmishing than any other place in the Colonies. Sometimes held by the British. Here the American Army rested on its march to capture Cornwallis at Yorktown 1781.”

This old '‘Jolly Post” was located on part of the Waddy Tract, of which I spoke at the beginning of this paper, and we believe he built the north section of the building as his residence in 1683. William Penn established a post office in Frankford in 1683, and Henry Waddy was made postmaster and given author- ity to establish a coach line to New Castle on the south, and the falls of the Delaware on the north. No doubt Henry Waddy enlarged his house when these appointments were made, and thus started a Post Inn, afterwards being known as “The Jolly Post Boy”, and later as the “Jolly Post”. It is therefore reasonable to date the “Jolly Post” from 1683.

There is mention in the will of Henry Waddy, who died November 25, 1694, of the disposal, to his daughter Ann Coney and her husband, Richard S., of certain real estate “land or ])lantation with all houses, barns, orchards, gardens, fences, en- closures, buildings and improvements thereon”, which their trustees disposed of four years later to one Robert Adams in 1698.

Before me is a copy of The P cnnsylvauia Chronicle of March 14, 1768, I quote in part:

“To be sold * * * on the premises in Oxford Townshij), in the County of Philadelphia, the noted Inn called The Sign of the Jolly Post, * * * being a commodious and ])leasant, lofty situation, containing about twenty acres of land, about eight of which are well timbered, a young orchard with about two hundred a]q)le trees, a convenient house, kitchen, stables, shed and trough to feed horses in, a well of good water just before the door, (and many a drink 1 have had from it) a good garden with sundry arbors therein, very jdeasant in the summer season for any j)crson riding out to take the air, as the road is generally very good between the ])remises and the City. Any ])erson inclining to ])ur- ebase .same may know the terms by a]q)lying to me.

64

Joseph Thornhill.” (He being the proprietor at that time.)

Joseph Thornhill was owner of the Jolly Post until May 2, 1787. John Papley with others, then became owners, until his death February 5, 1795. His widow with others sold it to Dr. Enoch Edwards for £3000 Pennsylvania money.

Eebruary 11, 1799, Dr. Edwards sold the Inn, retaining some of the ground, to George Webster for £2000. George Webster died in 1808, and his executors sold the property to Jacob Coats in 1814. His widow sold the house to Joseph Comly in 1851. In 1859 it was sold by sheriff’s sale to Joseph D. Koecher, architect, who sold it back to Caroline Comly in 1861. Mrs. Comly died in 1881, (I remember her ) and her heirs in 1894 sold the property to Edwin Forrest Smith for $11,500. At this time the property was renovated from drawings which I made. Edwin Forrest Smith died in 1905 and on August 17, 1910 his widow, Elizabeth Smith, sold it to the Erankford Land Company, who transferred it to the William M. Erance Company, and I was one of that Company.

The old Jolly Post was demolished in January and Eebruary, 1911, to make room for the modern stores now standing on the site, and one of which has on it the bronze tablet mentioned above.

Part of the original south wall of old Jolly Post is now a party wall of one of the modern stores occupying the site, and is visible from the Erankford “L”. There is much more to tell of the history of “Jolly Post”, of its romances and tragedies, but again we will leave that for our novelist. However, I do want to tell you of an incident recorded by Dr. Wm. B. Dixon:

“When Captain Stephen C. Paul was proprietor of Jolly Post, at the time of the Mexican War, a town character went to Peter Castor’s blacksmith shop just above Jolly Post and stole a horse shoe from him, afterwards selling it back to unsuspecting Peter for three cents. With this three cents he went to Mr. Paul at the Jolly Post and bought a ‘three-cent nip’. Then he told his cronies, with great gusto, how he had “robbed Peter to pay Paul.” (Whiskey was 10 cents and 12 cents a quart at any grocery store in those days.)

65

As the “Jolly Post” was a Post Hotel, it was the stopping place for all coaches which ran between Philadelphia and New York. I like to think of the activities, the excitement and color of the arrival and departure of the post coaches, the change of horses and the conversation of the travelers. Of the fashionable festivities in the Ball Room, of the dancing classes of the young belles of Frankford. Of the blossoming cherry trees and a])]de trees, of the lilac bushes, the shaded walks and arbors. Of the arrival of the young Philadelphia dandies with their sweethearts, after a spirited drive back of prancing horses, to enjoy the toddies or the strawberries and cream. Or on winter days, of the arrival of a hundred or more sleighs, the merry parties alighting, receiv- ing refreshments and warming themselves before the glowing log-fire in the spacious, friendly fireplace.

Before me is a copy of the Procupine’s Gazette Vol. 1 — No. 169, published by William Cobbett, opj)osite Christ Church, Mon- day, September 18, 1797, which gives us an idea of the desirability of Frankford as a place of residence and of the beauty of the landscape surrounding the “Jolly Post” — 1 quote: —

“For sale at Auction at Frankford on Monday the 25th in.st.

Sixteen lots of Ground of dififerent sizes On several streets of that thriving healthy and agreeable village.”

‘‘They are situated at the upper part of Frankford in front of the “Jolly Post” tavern, and command a most beautiful view of the adjacent country. New streets are now being opened there by the subscriber, and that ])art of the town must afford both for private retirement and public benefits a very de.sirahlc situa- tion. Some of the lots are ])articularly well situated for building on, and others for pasture. The sale will he held at the “Jolly Post” and begin at 3 o’clock.

Enoch ]u:>wards

N.B. If the weather should he very had, the .sale will be held on the next day, Se])tcmber 15th.

66

Reluctantly turning our steps from “Jolly Post” with so much still to be said, to the southwest corner of the present Orthodox Street and Frankford Avenue, there stood the old stone house owned by Gardner Fulton, whom 1 remember.

Mr. Fulton was an artist of great ability, known for his animal paintings on many circus wagons built in Frankford by Thomas Castor, and he was a talented Shakespearean actor and scholar. At an earlier time Alonzo de Bettencourt, a Spanish nobleman, exiled from Cuba where his father was Governor- General, also lived in this house. A fine Colonial mantel from this house now adds charm to the beauty of William Henry Smedley’s residence in Frankford. Another one is in the Friends’ Hospital, Frankford.

Matthias W. Baldwin, 1795-1866, founder of the Baldwin Locomotive Works, had a watch and clock business in a little store of the Fulton House on the ground floor, facing Frankford Road or, the old King’s Highway. He died at his country home on the Delaware at Wissinoming. just above Frankford, and still standing. The building of the Hermon Presbyterian Church at Frankford Avenue and Harrison Street, was “his last beneficent act before he closed his earthly mission.”

Colonel Burns’ house was below the Fulton House. Colonel Burns made a fortune in Spain ; lived in England, and later owned a plantation in the South. Came to Philadelphia, thence to Frank- ford, and is buried in the historical Presbyterian Church Burial Grounds in Frankford, at Frankford Avenue and Church Street. Colonel Burns served in the war of 1812. His home was a fine large house noted for its garden. In the rear was the ice house, fruit and nut trees; the English walnut trees were particularly tempting to us boys, I played in and around the grounds. This house had the first brick pavement in Frankford, and Colonel Burns took delight in strutting up and down it, swinging his gold- headed cane. From the front of his property he had an un- obstructed view toward the Delaware River.

Farther down Frankford Avenue, and still on the west side, stood one of the oldest houses in Frankford; it was the house of \¥illiam Huckle. Mr. Huckle was born in 1759, in England, and served in the Royal Guards as a young man, but at the outbreak of the Revolution he took service under General Washington, as a captain and afterwards a major.

67

In 1794 he took part in quelling the insurrection in Western Pennsylvania. He was friendly with Washington and was ac- tive in all military affairs. On his white horse in front of his house he reviewed the Philadelphia City Troop at different times as they were en route to Trenton or New York over Frankford Avenue (the King’s Highway) through Frankford.

One of his sons, Robert, a veteran of the War of 1812, oc- cupied the imposing house (still standing) on the west side of Frankford Avenue above Foulkrod Street. Some forty years ago Dr. James T. Ross bought this propertly. 1 designed some changes to it for him at that time, and saved the old boxwood gardens.

In removing a partition 1 found a solid shot and a pair of leather pistol holsters. Sometime later I mentioned the inci- dent to Samuel Huckle, a fellow-architect, who had a pair of old pistols coming down from the Huckle family, but no holsters. 1 gave him the holsters and the pistols fitted perfectly, so after many years of separation the pistols and the holsters were again united.

At the south end of Frankford and close to Frankford Creek, on the old King’s Highway, stood in my boyhood days, the Womrath House “Violet Hill’’, also known as “Elm Hill”. The Public Ledger of June 30, 1907, said:

“During the Revolution the house was occupied by Dr. Enoch Edwards, who was said to have been the brother of Johnathan Edwards, the younger. While IClwards resided there, the legend runs, members of the Conti- nental Congress occasionally visited him, and it is related that on July 8. 1776, the day the Declaration of Inde- ])endence was read to the ])0])ulace in the State House Square. Jefferson, the framer of the immortal document, together with a few other members of the Continental Congress, went out to Erankford to spend the day with Dr. Edwards.”

About six hundred feet (1)00) in the rear of the old house was, until about thirty years ago, an inviting (.'olonial summer house. To this comfortable retreat, according to tradition, the little party retired on that histf)ric occasion and s])cnt the day

68

very agreeably in a social way, and there Jefferson read to the selected circle the newly adopted "Declaration.”

David S. Rorer, an old Frank fordian, whom I knew, in his recollections of “Main Street in the 30’s”, (published in 1909), wrote :

‘The \\ onirath House was formerly the country seat of Henry Drinker. * * * * 'ppe Journal of Eliz-

aheth Drinker, wife of Henry Drinker, was ])uhlished a few years ago. It contains much history concerning the days before and during the Revolutionary War. On the Womrath estate stood an old-fashioned summer house in which, tradition states, Thomas Jefferson made a rough draft of the Declaration of Independence. ♦ * ♦ *

The tradition may have its foundation in the fact that a number of delegates to the Continental Congress in 1774, met in Frankford and discussed the action to he taken in Congress that fall and the following winter concerning such a Declaration.” 1 have already made mention of this instance.

This is substantially the story we hoys were told as we played with Arthur Womrath and his brothers around the fine old gardens and in the Rose Garden with its box bush lined walks, and camped under the old, old trees, and on hot sum- mer days, in the historic old Summer House ate our watermelons after they had been cooled by burying them in the ice stored in the ice house with ice from the nearby Frankford Creek. In the rear of the Womrath property there is still standing the residence of Dr. John Ruan, a close friend of Dr. Benjamin Rush.

The old grist mill along Frankford Creek, which I men- tioned previously as having been purchased by Penn from the Swedes, played an important part in the Revolutionary War. What subject matter for our novelist in the following incident! Lydia Darragh, overhearing a conversation of some of General Howe’s officers quartered in her home in Philadelphia, of a con- templated attack on Washington’s Army, used the excuse that she was going for flour, and passing through the lines rode to this mill on Frankford Creek, and imparted her knowledge to the officers of the Continental outposts stationed along Frankford Creek, thus warning the Army at White Marsh.

69

On Powder Mill Lane to the west of the mill, and on Frank- ford Creek lived Captain Stephen Decatur and his famous son, Commodore Decatur, who attended school in the old Academy, (which my grandfather, Thomas Castor also attended in 1827.)

Close to the southern boundry of Frankford, in Flarrogate — Northern Liberties — facing Frankford Road, stood the stone house known as “Cedar Grove”. Started in 1748 by Elizabeth Coats, it was enlarged in 1799, and passed to the ownership of the Isaac Wistar Morris Family, through the daughter of Eliz- abeth Coats Paschall, and was occupied until 1888. Thomas Coats, the father of Elizabeth, gave each of his children a golden JACOBUS, with the injunction never to spend it unless in need. There is one of these coins in existence, through the “Cedar Grove” line, and is a precious heirloom. The house was taken

down and rebuilt on the Lansdowne Plateau in Fairmount Park,

*

as the gift of Miss Lydia Thompson Morris.

On the east side of the King’s Highway, at what is now

the corner of Church Street, stands the Presbyterian Church.

The original building of 1770, was used as a prison and hospital

for some Hessians from the Battle of Trenton. The graveyard

is the resting place of many old Frankfordians, among whom

is the progenitor of the Castor family, John George Castor, born

March 5. 1710, died December 24, 1797.

On the front lawn of the Church are markers reading —

“1675—1921

WASHINGTON

This road was marked out in 1675 as the King’s Highway and improved by the order of the Provincial Council 1686. William Penn travelled this road in going to his Manor “Pennsbury.” John Adams and delegates to the Continental Congress, 1775 ; Washington and his Army to Yorktown, 1781.

h'rected by the Frankford Hi.storical Society”

And another one reading —

GI<:NEkALS HIGHWAY Route of General Washington’s triumphal journey.

70

December 3 — 2.^, 1783, New York to Annapolis to re- sign as Comniander-in-Chief of the American Army.

Marker erected by Donegal Chapter N.S. D.A.R.

1732— 1932”

In this same block is the old “Leake" House, recently re- conditioned and now a Real Estate Office. A bronze tablet has Ijeen placed on this house by the Frankford Historical Society to mark the spot where the arch was erected in honor of La- Fayette’s visit in 1824, which event I have already mentioned.

Close by (at 4217 Main Street) is the location of the house where the first Building and Loan Association in the United States was organized, January 10, 1831. The books of this “Ox- ford Provident Building Association of Philadelphia County” are in the archives of the Frankford Historical Society. Jesse Y. Castor was the first Secretary.

Coming up Frankford Avenue, and still on the east side, back on Oxford Street, then Gillingham’s Lane, stood an old book bindery. (It was afterwards converted into two dwellings). When James Fenimore Cooper’s novel “The Last of the Mo- hicans” was printed in Frankford, it was bound in this book bindery in Frankford.

To the east of “Cedar Grove” House, in the Y formed by the New York Division of the Pennsylvania Railroad and the Atlantic City Branch, at Frankford Junction Station, stands “Chalkley Hall”, the small wing built before 1732, and the main part about 1776.

The first owner, Thomas Chalkley, came to Philadelphia in 1701, and for his health’s sake came to Frankford in 1723. He was a merchant and a minister of the Society of Friends ; a great traveler in this country, preaching the gospel not only here, but in the West Indies, England, Scotland, Ireland and Germany. He died on the island of Tortola, 4th of the 9th month, 1741. His journal relates many interesting experiences, one of which Whit- tier recalls in “Snow Bound”. His will provided — “If I die at home I desire my corpse to be laid in Friends Burial Ground in Philadelphia, by the side of my former dear wife so as there may be room for my present wife (if she please), so that I may

71

lie between them, but this particular I leave as a thing indifferent, it’s only to show my love to them both till death.”

Thomas Chalkley bought the plantation in several tracts, some three hundred and forty acres along the road lead- ing from Frankford Road to Point-no-Point (VVheatsheaf Lane), and along the great road leading from Philadelphia to Point-no- Point (Richmond Road, or Point Road) and extending to Frank- ford Creek. Then there was additional ground bought for the boat landing.

The various owners of Chalkley Hall have been Abel James and wife, 1741-1789; John Drinker 1789; Frederick Pigon 1789- 1792; Lawrence John Ledger le Senechal de Kercado, a refugee from San Domingo, 1792-1794; John Nicholson 1794-1797 ; Joseph Potts and Joseph Kirkbride 1797-1798; Samuel Allen 1798-1814; Samuel Yorke 1814-1817. The property was bought by John Wetherill in 1817, and Edward Wetherill in 1893. It is now owned by Taylor and Stokes.

When John Greenleaf Whittier lived in Philadelphia and was editor of the Pennsylvania Freeman, he was a frequent vis- itor to friends in Frankford. His visits to Chalkley Hall inspired him to write the poem “Chalkley Hall”, and to note — “During my temporary residence in Philadelphia in 1838, the quiet and beautiful scenery around the ancient village of Frankford fre- quently attracted me from the heat and bustle of the city”, and so part of his poem reads, —

“How bland and sweet the greetings of this

breeze

To him who flees

From crowded street and red wall’s weary

gleam,

'rill far behind him like a hideous dream The close dark city lies !

And hence this scene, in sunset glory warm, —

Its woods around.

And still stream winding on in light and

shade.

Its .soft, green meadows and its upland glade, — •

'I'o me is holy ground.”

72

But alas, when I visited Chalkley Hall a few weeks ago, what a sad contrast. Its approach is through the wire gates to the grounds of Taylor and Stokes. American Engineering Plant No. 2. The walls of the house and harn are still in good con- dition : the windows are boarded up ; the drives, walks and woods have disappeared ; the panel work, the fine old stairway, mantels and doors are no more. There remain some of the original stone floor, door jambs, panelling and a small section of the stairway leading to the attic. The framing of the roof construction would delight the architect and the master builder. All the spacious hall- ways and high ceilinged rooms are filled with wood patterns for castings, almost to the ceilings.

Above Chalkley Hall was the “Wain Grove” house, des- tined afterwards, like Chalkley Hall, to be in the midst of the bustle of factories and railroads,

“Wain Grove” was built in 1772, was three stories high, with hipped roof and octagonal ends. It had a Great Hall and Library in the south wing, with carved mantels, while the dining room was in the other wing. The plantation had an abundance of fine shade trees and a view of the river. This was the home of Robert Wain, who, with his cousin Jesse, was a successful merchant and importer.

“Wain Grove” so beautifully situated, was known for its hospitality, the family coach, driven by the coachman in purple livery, with two footmen on the postboard, similarly liveried, conveyed frequent guests to and from Philadelphia over the Frank ford Road.

Near “Wain Grove” there still stands in its dilapidated con- dition, and partly occupied by an Italian family, another noted Colonial house knov/n as “Port Royal.”

From Robert and Richard Wain of “Wain Grove”, Edward Stiles purchased, August 6, 1761, some one hundred and thirteen (113) acres of ground adjoining “Wain Grove”, and erected a mansion known as “Port Royal.” Edward Stiles was a great- grandson of John Stiles, a settler in Bermuda as early as 1635. Born near Port Royal in Bermuda, he so named his Frankford home. Architecturally it was representative of the Georgian style, and was more nearly true to that period both as to exterior and interior, than any of the other houses I have mentioned. It

73

liad a broad hallway in the middle, on either side of which were high ceilinged rooms, with fine panelled walls and embellished mantels, all of which were later removed by the DuPonts.

George W. Lukens whom I knew, and who died in 1899, owned the house and lived in it. His will bequeathed the prop- erty to the Masonic Order. They did not accept it ; then as pro- vided by the will, St. Marks P. E. Church of Frankford was to receive it, but they also refused it.

Previously I mentioned the sad experience which befell Mrs. Edward Stiles while on her return from Port Royal to Phila- delphia, with a boy-servant, and how she lost her chaise and Henry Drinker’s horse to a troop of British Cavalry. Before this incident the place had been looted of furniture, ten slaves, provisions, coaches and horses, thus records Elizabeth Drinker in her Diary.

The Pennsylvania Mercury and Universal Advertiser of Friday, December 23, 1785, printed a petition to the Hon. Thomas Mifflin, Esq., Speaker of the General Assembly, from Edward Stiles “* * * Setting forth that after an absence of two years and upwards returning from Bermuda, * * he was made a prisoner on parole and retired to his country seat near Frankford. when the British entered the city in 1777 • * * *

He left his country seat and effects in Frankford to the care of his servants and came to Philadelphia, intending to return again as soon as possible j * * * * during his absence a

party of Captain Craig’s troops broke into and fixed their quar- ters in his said country seat, and a number of slaves and other considerable property were either taken away or destroyed ; that sometime after he received a notice for the sale of confiscated estates, purporting that his negroes were seized by an ordinance of the then Council of Safety, and to be sold unless redeemed at their valuation * ♦ + =i:

The estate of Edward Stiles was worth £70,000, with an income of £4000. He died in 1804 and in his town residence two iron chests were found containing about $23,000 in cash. The United States Bank purchased the chests. They afterwards came into |K)Ssession of the Girard National Bank, and became mu.seum pieces as having belonged to Stephen Girard.

While Mr. Tuikens was making alterations to Port Royal,

74

an earthen jar containing a number of old gold and silver coins was found in the foundation under the sill.

There were other fine old Colonial houses and ])lantations worthy of mentioning here, but time forbids; also the old schools; old churches; town characters; folklore stories; the social life and the stage coach lines streams and streets still bearing Indian names of local tribes ; the organization of the first fire depart- ment in 1798 at Jolly Post. Then there was the meeting of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania in the old Frankford “Academy” for the September term, 1799; also the many priceless relics, valuable books, documents, maps and photographs in the archives of the Frankford Historical Society.

You have been most patient in listening to this abbreviated account of “Colonial Frankford”. Now that it is finished, I am conscious of my inability and unworthiness to do justice to the early history of Frankford. and so to my ancestors, to all old Frankfordians, and to those who have made history as they traveled up and down the old King’s Highway, and to yon, Gentlemen, I offer my apologies.

As I know Frankford of today and am in some small meas- ure familiar with its historic grandeur of Colonial days, I have great respect for and now pay homage in this article to the men who have made history in Frankford, and to those patriots who hallowed the old King’s Highway by their travels.

My feelings are well expressed by a letter written by Dr. Ben- jamin Rush in 1812, to John Adams, on the occasion of Dr. Rush’s visit to his ancestral burying grounds and the place of his birth. Byberry, just above Frankford. I quote in part:

“While standing and considering * * ♦ thoughts

ran wild and my ancestors seemed to stand before me

* * ♦ * |-Q gay — ‘What means this gentleman

by thus intruding upon our repose?’ And I seem to say, ‘Dear and venerable friends be not disturbed, I am *

* * here to do homage.’ ”

75

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

Dr. Benjamin Rush

by Eleanor E. Wright, Jan. 1913

The Jolly Post

by Eleanor E. Wright

Erankford and the Main Street 65 Years Ago (1842)

by Dr. William B. Dixon

Old Erankford Academy (1800-1897)

by Robert T. Corson

Edward Stiles

by Gurnsey A. Hallowed, Esq.

The Main Street of Erankford during the “Thirties”

by David S. Rorer

Colonial Homes of Philadelphia

by Harold Donaldson Eberlein and Horace Mather Lippincott

Old Roads out of Philadelphia Watson’s Annals of Philadelphia Elizabeth Drinker’s Diary

by John T. Paris

Historical and Industrial Celebra- tion— 1912

by Gurnsey A. Hallowed, Esq.

Bristol Pike

by Rev. S. F. Hotchkin, M.A. 1893

General LaPayette’s Journey from Brandywine to Bethlehem

by B. F. Fackenthal

The Real Boston Tea Party Historical Society of Erankford

by John Hyde Preston

Memories of the Jolly Post

by Mary P. Aden

Criticisms and Miscellaneous Data

by William Overington, Jr. and Joseph Jackson

Colonial Newspapers in the jKjssession of the Author

76

HEMLOCKS

(Read at a meeting of the Society, May 21, 1937)

By Charles F. Jenkins

It would be most appropriate, in discussing hemlocks, to con- sider them from the standpoint of their importance to ornamental horticulture and not as valued forest trees. Since the settlement of America, the Canada Hemlock has been an important source of wealth. Its lumber is useful for many purposes, and its bark, through two centuries one of the chief sources of tannin, is used in the manufacture of leather. But the accessible hemlock forests in the eastern United States have, for the most part, disappeared and the tanneries are now turning to cheaper sources of supply.

Our great botanists, our horticulturists, our writers on nature, and our poets all unite in praising the gracefulness and the dignity of the hemlock, from an ornamental point of view. A. J. Downing, the father of landscape architecture in America, wrote of it nearly 100 years ago as follows :

“For airy gracefulness, and the absence of that stiffness more or less prevalent in evergreens we must be allowed, therefore, to claim the first place for the hemlock, as a tree for the lawn or park."’ Many of my listeners will recall Longfellow’s translation :

“Oh hemlock tree ! Oh hemlock tree !

How glorious are thy branches !

’Tis not alone in summer time But in the winter’s frost and rime Oh hemlock tree ! Oh hemlock tree !

How glorious are thy branches.”

Dr. Charles S. Sargent, Dr. Alfred Rehder, Ernest H. Wil- son, Dr. Liberty H. Bailey, Thomas Aleehan and scores of other botanical scientists have extolled its beauty. Among our nature lovers and writers. Henry D. Thoreau, John Burroughs, and particularly John Muir have written of the deep impression its lovely gracefulness has made on them.

Hemlocks have not been found growing naturally in Europe, in the southern hemisphere nor in Africa. They are indig- enous to the Atlantic seaboard of North America, from Labrador to northern Georgia and xA.labama, and in isolated stands as far west as Minnesota. Here are growing two species, Canada Hem- lock, (Tsuga canadensis) and Carolina Hemlock (Tsuga caroliniana) . On the northwest Pacific coast are two species.

77

Mountain Hemlock (Tsuga Mertensiana) and Western Hemlock (Tsuga heterophylla) . There are likewise two species in Japan, Tsuga Sieboldi and Tsuga diversifolia. In China there are two, Tsuga chinensis and Tsuga yunnanensis. Further west on the slopes of the Himalayas is the moisture-loving Tsuga dumosa.

Tsuga, meaning “the mother tree”, the name of the genus, comes from Japan. When our Canada Hemlock was introduced to Europe it was included with the pines in the genus Pinus. Later, the French botanist Michaux grouped it with the firs; still later it was placed with the spruces, until an Austrian used the name Tsuga as a section of his genus Pinus. Finally the cele- brated French botanist, Carriere, classified all hemlocks into a separate group under the generic name Tsuga. Thus this im- portant section of our North American conifers bears a Japanese name given it by an Austrian, confirmed by a Frenchman, and now accepted by botanists generally.

How THE Name Hemlock Was Derived

How it received its common, everyday name is interesting. When introduced to English people, our native eastern hemlock was considered and called a spruce. Because its leaves and branches resembled the European Poison-hemlock, (Conium maculatum), a weed of the Carrot Family well known in Europe, it was called Hemlock-spruce — that it, the spruce with leaves like Poison-hemlock. When botanists determined it was not a spruce, the name hemlock continued as the common, everyday name.

Visitors to the Hemlock Arboretum at Far Country often ask what part of hemlocks is poisonous. No part of our hemlock is poisonous. They confuse it with the European weed. Poison- hemlock, which I mentioned above. A decoction of this biennial plant, Conium maculatum, was used by the ancient Athenians to put criminals to death. With such a dose j)oor old Socrates was killed. Though native to Europe, Poison-hemlock is naturalized in North and South America.

Until you get to know them intimately, hemlock trees look pretty much alike, and there are many gardeners who cannot tell a hemlock from a spruce or fir. We have gathered at the Hemlock Arboretum 160 specimen.s- — at least one of all the rare foreign species and, in addition, probably 30 to 40 variations of our common hemlock. 1 say “probably” because we arc still classify-

78

ing them and. without seeming to boast, it is safe to say that nowhere in the world are to he found, at one place, so many species of Tsnga and variants of these sjxicies.

The natural habitat of hemlocks is in dampish soil where their roots may he cool. In favored locations, hemlocks grow to a great age and height. Mr. R. D. Forbes, of the United States Forest Service, sent me a photograph of a hemlock stump which had 560 annual rings of growth and was 50 inches in diameter, and an old lumberman in southern New York State recalls seeing in his youth a stump with 800 rings. Near my home in the

P.A.TH LEADING TO HEMLOCK ARBORETUM

W issahickon Valley, which is a part of Fairmount Park, is a monarch which was a seedling when William Penn came in 1682. This specimen is now 125 feet high. 13 feet five inches in girth at four and a half feet from the ground.

Varieties

Now for some of the varieties of hemlocks. In 1870, General Joseph Howland discovered four little seedlings in the mountains back of his home at Fishkill on the Hudson. He brought them home, gave one to his nextdoor neighbor, Henry W. Sargent,

79

another to his friend H. H. Hunnewell of Wellesley, Mass., and the third to Dr. Charles S. Sargent, head of the Arnold Ar- boretum. The fourth he planted on his own place. The last two have survived and are now what I call “vernal fountains of per- ]>etual joy”. From probably all of these original trees grafts were taken and propagated. By 1876 the old Parsons Nursery at Flushing, N. Y., had plants on the market, and their display at the Centennial Exposition created a sensation among horticultur- ists and garden lovers. Discriminating planters hastened to secure specimens of these graceful, weeping trees and literally thousands have been grown and sold. Sargent’s Weeping Hemlock probably is the best known of all varieties of Tsuga canadensis.

These mutations of our native hemlock dif¥er in manner of growth. Some are tall and spindling, some are dwarf and creeping on the ground. One little dwarf of three inches in height, now 10 years old, always attracts attention. Then there are variations of foliage and of individual leaves — some large, some dark, others light green and moss-like. One has foliage like a yew. There is a golden variety and one with silver tips to the branches. There is a globose form and a fastigiate one, and specimens which have varying degrees of pendulous branches. One particularly interest- ing form has a hundred or more stems growing in the form of a symmetrical bush, like Irish Juniper. 1 would like to extend a cordial invitation to everyone interested! — nurserymen, horticul- turists, botanists, and amateurs — to visit the Hemlock Arboretum and see for themselves the tricks nature has played in the seedling offspring of our native tree. Incidentally, I should also like to add that we will be glad to send, free of charge, a co])y of the Hemlock Arboretum’s most recent bulletin to anyone who wishes it. Address all such requests to me at Kitchens Lane, German- town, Alt. Airy P. O., Philadelj)hia, Pa.

Some of the species are not hardy in our locality. Himalayan Hemlock (d'suga dumosa) and those from the province of Yun- nan in China and the Island of Formosa are growing in pots and tubs and have to be moved to a shelter in the winter. We find that W’estern Hemlock, native of the northwest coast, is also unhaj)])y with us. Chinese Hemlock from the mountain regions of western C hina does not mind our climate and last year made a growth of 20 inches. One of my specimens is grown from seed which was

80

obtained from the Siin-Yat Sen I ’ark in Canton. China, and thus it has a special historical significance today.

In common with other conifers, hemlocks are not adapted to city street planting or for the small front yards of snhurhan homes. 1 have found these trees not particnlar as to lime ; in fact, they seem to have iiniisnal adaptability as to soil. As a single lawn specimen or part of a group they are at their best, and there is no other tree that will grow and thrive as they do when planted as an understory in a mature forest grove or along its borders. They make an excellent hedge but must he trimmed at least twice a year ; do not neglect a hemlock hedge or it will become thin and scrawny.

Most nurserymen carry hemlocks, and several nurseries spe- cialize in the dwarf forms and variations. If you have only room for two unusual specimens, plant a Sargent Weeping Hemlock (Tsuga canadensis pendula), and a Japanese Hemlock (Tsuga diversifolia) . the small species from Japan. My largest specimen bloomed and fruited this year for the first time. While the blos- soms of our native species are inconspicuous and often go un- noticed, the bloom on Japanese Hemlock presented a wonderfully beautiful sight. The tree was covered completely with lavender and bluish blossoms.

Different species of trees have their warm admirers and friends. Throughout New England the native White or Wey- mouth Pine is a universal favorite. There has been a disposition to crown it as the “kingly tree” and give it highest rank.

The pine is called the “kingly” tree It well deserves full royalty.

The hemlock’s called the “princely” tree This lower rank is not for me.

Right here and now. Oh hemlock tree,

A royal crown is given thee.

Not prince, but equal, “Queenly” tree In beauty, grace and symmetry,

Full honor his, great honor hers.

The king and queen of conifers.

81

CHINESE PORCELAIN

(Read at a meeting of the Society, January 24, 1938)

By Lawrence J. Morris

Ceramics, the study of the art of Pottery, is derived from the Greek, Kepa/xo?.

The art belongs to all peoples, as one of the earliest develop- ments of primitive man ; and still widely carried on with meagre equipment, but with greatly improved technique, the result of ages of experiment.

Pottery, in its widest sense, includes all objects fashioned from clay, and hardened by fire — from bricks and tiles to the most delicate ornamental wares. In a narrower sense Pottery is restricted to the commoner wares, and the term Porcelain applied to the finer varieties, although Porcelain, should he restricted to certain well defined varieties of pottery.

The term, porcelain, is derived from the Italian Porcella — the courie shell, the beautifully polished shell surface of which caused application of the term to the ware. In turn the applica- tion of porcella to the courie shell is supposed to be due to its resemblance in shape to a pig’s hack.

True jirocelain is characterized by a translucent body, yet the term is loosely used for fine ware generally, commonly called China.

Pottery of all sorts is dejiendent upon two natural properties of clay — ])lasticity and convertibility under high heat into one of the most indestructible ])roducts. Pottery clays have very wide distribution, and are of very varied jiroperties, composition and colour. These varying qualities primarily governed the nature of wares jiroduced by different countries and races. Even down to the 18th century the jiotters of any land could only obtain, on any extensive scale, the clays of their own immediate district. Einished wares, however, enjoyed much wider distribution.

Much attention must he given by archeologists to these facts in attributing a source of origin of a given sjiecimen ; and also, that local potters frc(juently tried to copy foreign wares. Under modern freer conditions of transport — the fine white burning clays of South of Ifngland are widely used in Eurojie and Amer-

82

ica for modern wares, but such conditions did not obtain in earlier periods.

Primitive races in remote ages, as now, used suclr local clays as found on the surface or on river banks, working the material roughly with sticks, stones, hands and feet to render it fairly uniform in consistency and modelling by hand such shapes as need or fancy dictated, and drying in the sun. Before long the discovery was made that the added use of fire produced a better and more enduring article. The attempt to control the heat to minimize cracking and uneven burning gradually evolved a rude kiln, probably at first merely a few stones set about the open fireplace. Later some genius discovered it was easier to build up a clay vessel if the material was placed on a block of wood, or a stone turned by another person, or by foot power, while he used both hands in moulding; and thus the ‘‘Potter’s Wheel” — virtually a vertical lathe was invented. The myths of all older civilzations Egyptian, Chaldaean, Scythian, Chinese, etc., tell how the Potter’s Wheel was brought down from heaven by one of their gods to their particularly favoured race. Possibly the idea sprang from the brain of a mere man struggling to his task.

Early writers on pottery attribute the art entirely to the inventions of Egypt. China or Persia, or other early race. This is but partially true so far as other races are concerned. Wherever clay was found pottery developed. Potters like hunters, herdsmen, farmers, carpenters, smiths, etc. were the result of local neces- sity and these workers slowly created and perpetuated traditional methods. Like progress was made by Mayas in Guatemala, Incas in Peru, Aztecs in Mexico, and by all our American Indian peoples.

It was early discovered that even in the same district all clavs did not burn to the same colour. At once colour and other decorations arose, at first incised or applied. From such begin- nings Egypt evolved schemes of glowing colour and brilliant glazes, and the Greeks produced their marvels of plastic form. Later, when these nations were overthrown by Rome, the con- querors spread some slight knowledge from the Euphrates to the Atlantic and from Egypt to the Walls of Hadrian. Roman civilization lit potters fires never since extinguished. The Roman Empire fell, yet pottery in simple form was slowly revived and modified by communities of IMonastic orders, which replaced

83

the Roman legions as the great civilizing influence in Europe. Meantime, Egypt and the Near East, continued, in a debased form the splendours of their glorious past, and glazed and painted pottery continued to be made by traditional methods.

What ])art the Byzantines and Persians played in these obscure times we are now beginning to realize. At least we know many interesting wares continued to be there fashioned ; when all over Europe the sole evidence of their potters skill were rough crocks of red or drab clay, with perhaps green or yellow lead glazes.

Mohammedan conquests spread their art to the West, reach- ing there its highest expression. Methods and techniques hitherto confined to Persia and the Near East spread from Spain and the South of Erance as far as to India. In the Moslem lands a whitish mixture of sand and clay was used, or a light reddish clay, coated with a facing of white clay, or a tin enamel, on which splendid decoration patterns in vivid pigments, or brilliant iridescent lustres were painted. As early as the 12th century this superior Moslem pottery attracted Europeans as articles of luxury. Tradi- tion asserts that Saracen potters were brought to Italy, France and Burgundy to teach their practices. In Italy and Southern France the native wares were coated with a white “slip”, through which rude ])atterns were drawn, and ])ainted on in yellows, greens and ])ur])lish black. Increasing intercourse with Spain introduced Tin Enamel like the Hispano-Moresque wares.

Primitive potters used little preparation of clay, and it is not unusual to find hits of stone, gravel, etc. embedded in the paste of such wares. No race however, practiced the art for long with- out discovery that vessels were not so aj)t to crack in firing, or lose their shape in firing, if fine .sand or ])ounded “potsherds” were added to the clay.

Races that have passed beyond the Stone Age and have learned the use of metals. univer.sally used .such prc])aration of material. Many primitive nations burnished pottery, after firing; and in other ca.ses coated objects with waxy, or resinous sub- stances. Possibly the black varnish of ( Irecian vases was so ob- tained. Such a coating is merely a suh.stitute for glaze, by those whf) have not mastered the technical secrets of true glaze. A true glaze is made by superficial layers of molten material fired on the clay .substance.

84

Every kind of potters clay has its own type of glaze. In early days the range of form, glaze, or colour was predecided for the potter by the material at his command. Clays that cannot be fired at highest temperatures, always find lead glazes most practical : while those fired at such high heats destroy some colouring materials. A clay suitable for high heat, to which large quantities of sand (silica) be added, may be glazed by vapours of common salt. iMixtures rich in feldspar, like Chinese or Euro- pean porcelains, can be glazed by fusing feldspathic materials on them.

The earliest known specimens of glazed ware are of Egyp- tian origin, but the practice probably developed independently wherever a knowledge of the elements of glass making had spread as all the early glazes were of the alkaline type, which must first be fused into a glass, before they are applicable to pottery. Egyptian and Assyrian glazes were silicates of soda and lime, containing very little alumina, and no lead. These are very uncertain in use and can only be applied to pottery unusually rich in silica and deficient in clay ; and cannot be used on ordinary clay w’ares, except when the surface has been coated with a highly silicious layer. This was the practice of Persian, Rhodian, Syrian and Egyptian potters in early Middle Ages. At a very early period it was discovered that glazes containing lead oxide would adhere to ordinary pottery when alkaline glazes would not. This practice was extensively used in Egypt and the Near East in the Ptolemaic Period ; and atlhough the Romans them- selves used almost no glaze of any kind, the pottery that suc- ceeded theirs, both in Western Europe and the Byzantine Empire, was generally covered with glazes rich in lead. Throughout Europe and most of the world, leaded glazes have been continu- ously used and improved for all ordinary pottery. Only with certain special hard fired wares have these lead glazes been suc- cessfully replaced.

The hardest fired varieties are the most durable and glazes of hard porcelain are more unchangeable than lead glazes, and these in turn than the alkaline type.

Mixtures rich in feldspar, such as used for Chinese, or European Porcelain, can be glazed at high heats by melting feld- spathic material upon them.

Colour. The earliest decoration was by use of varying earths

85

and clays, ranging from white to gray, cream, buff, red, brown or black. Before the invention of glaze, one variety of clay daubed on another gave variety — and then native earth, other than clays, containing iron, manganese, cobalt, etc. were gradually used. Some of the earliest glazes were really coloured glass; contain- ing copper or iron: from which yellow, green and turquoise were obtained. Before time of crusades Persia and Egypt had further devloped glazing by a soda-lime application. Objects shaped in good clay were covered with a white, highly silicious coat, — giving a good ground for painted colours — and then fired, — giving good results. These are known as Underglaze Colours being applied before firing the glaze. The most extensive applica- tion of coloured glazes was by the Chinese, who developed this type before they used painted patterns, in underglaze colour.

The earliest Chinese Porcelains, as well as their hard fired Stoneware (out of which porcelain arose) were decorated in this manner, and the beauty of their early “Sung” period coloured glazes has never been surpassed.

Very few underglaze colours could support the heat required for the exceedingly refractory feldspathic glazes of Chinese por- celain. The prevalence of Blue and White among early specimens arises from the fact that Cobalt was almost the only substance known to ])Otters of “Ming” Dynasty which would endure the high temperatures required to fuse their glazes. Consequently the Chinese were driven to invent methods of ])ainting in coloured fusible glasses over the already fired glaze, and using the coloured enamels such as used on metal work, hence the term Enamel Decoration applied to those colours painted over an already fixed glaze used previously for the glaze pro])er. Colour possibilities in any method of decoration are largely governed by the temperature at which the colour needs to he fired. Clay colours are more limited in range than the underglaze colours, and these, in turn, than the on glaze colours.

Gold, platinum and silver have been largely used from early 18th century as adjuncts to pottery decoration, especially on fine white earthenware and |M)ttery of last two centuries. At first gold leaf was a])])lied with a japanners .size; and was not fired to the glaze, hut later the metals have gradually been fired to the surface of the glaze, in like manner to enamel colours by mixing

86

the pulverized metal with a small projxn*tion of Ihix, or fusible ground glass.

The early Chinese and Japanese gilding appears, like the European, to have been “sized” or “watergilt”, not fired. It is believed the use of “fired” gold was taught the Oriental by the European in the 18th century. Today “liquid” gold is exported from Europe to China and japan for the use of potters.

By the end of 14th century knowledge of Tin Enamel was widespread in Italy, and preceded the glorious painted “Majol- ica” of 15th and 16th centuries. As a result of Italian Renais- sance this art spread widely from Italy and Spain to France, Holland and Germany, finally reaching England much later.

During the 15th and 16th centuries, Chinese Porcelain began to find its way into Europe. The whiteness of its substance, and marvelous translucence excited the attention of native potters and alchemists.

The first recorded European imitation of Chinese were was at Florence in 1575-85, by alchemists and potters under patronage of Francisco di Medici. This Florentine porcelain, the first European ware made in imitation of the Chinese, forms a connecting link between pottery and glass, ad may be considered either as pottery rendered translucent, or glass rendered opaque, by shaping and firing a mixture containing a large percentage of glass with a very little clay. After the cessation of these Floren- tine experiments, little or no European attempts are known for nearly a century.

In European countries at the beginning of 15th century we find only rudely fashioned and decorated wares, tracing the slow developmet of primitive native craft by the addition of Roman methods. Such wares are almost entirely for utility rather than ornament, clumsily fashioned, and if glazed at all, with coarse lead glazes. The finest expression of this native style occurs in Gothic Tile Pavements in France, Germany and England. The colours of these are entirely due to the clays, with no painting.

In the Far East the Chinese, the greatest race of potters the world has ever seen, were quietly gathering strength until from their glazed and hard fired pottery emerged marvelous white translucent porcelain, one of the wonders of the mediaeval world.

In China, as in every other country where pottery making has been practised for centuries, we find a natural progression

87

from primitive pottery akin in shape, decoration and manufacture to the pottery of other primitive races the world over.

In China too we find the early manufacture of bricks, tiles, etc. as in Egypt and Assyria, and then the usual succession of domestic utensils, funeral vases, and vessels for religious cere- monials.

There is no evidence that the Potter’s Wheel appeared in China earlier than elsewhere, and the Chinese potters have used the simple methods of carving, and "pressing” with molds, which preceded there as elsewhere the use of the potter’s wheel, even more than other nations.

In books of the “Chow” dynasty (1122-249 B.C.) the differ- ence between the processes of "throwing”, on a wheel, and of '‘pressing” from molds is clearly described, and it is instructive to note that many early as well as late forms of Chinese pottery are remarkably like their work in bronze — which of course was '“cast.” No definite date can be assigned to Chinese introduction of “glaze.”

The earliest glazed specimens are denoted by the Chinese to “Han” dynasty (206 B.C. — 220 A.D.) — a date much later than earliest known glazed ware of Egypt and Assyria. Perhaps the idea of coating a clay vessel with a glaze was derived by China from Chaldea or Assyria.

The Chinese, however, developed the potters art on their own lines, for we have ample evidence from very early times they fired their pottery to a much higher temperature than was com- mon in the west of Asia, and thereby discovered types of glaze and of ])Ottery that remained for centuries a mystery elsewhere. The glazed wares of Han dynasty already mentioned are quite unlike any contemporary pottery produced in Syria, Egyj)t, or luirope ; for the body of the ware is so hard that it can scarcely he scratched by a knife, and the dark -greenish glaze has become iridescent by age ; as though it contained oxide of lead. The low fired friable wares of Assyria, Egypt and Greece seem to have had no attraction for the Chinese, and the glazes on their hard-fired wares were naturally different.

The Chine.se aj)pear to have been the first to discover that, at a sufficiently high tem])erature ]>ottery can he glazed with powdered feldspathic rock mixed with lime. At fir.st these glazes were used on any ordinary refractory clay which might burn red.

88

drab, or buff, the germ of Chinese porcelain, the most advanced form of pottery the world has yet seen.

d'he pottery that preceded ])orcelain was not only the matrix out of which porcelain was developed, but in certain districts in China, where the necessary raw materials do not occur, similar wares have been continuously manufactured to this day. During the centuries the technique of this ]X)ttery has been greatly im- proved by developments in preparation and mixture of clays, the shaping and modelling of the wares, the introduction of coloured enamels or glazes, etc.

Two outstanding types of Chinese pottery — other than por- celain, have greatly influenced European pottery. No 1 Yi- Hsing-Yao. Pottery generally of unglazed fawn, red, or brown stoneware, made in Province of Kiang-Su. The general forms, are dainty and skillfully finished — small teapots, cups, etc. This was largely made in the Ming j)eriod A.D. 1308-1643 and later, and imported into Europe by the Portuguese.

This pottery and true Chinese porcelain were totally dif- ferent in nature and origin, but potters of northern Europe re- garded every kind of pottery coming from the Far East as a species of porcelain, and imitation of this Yi-Hsing-Yao was widespread during late 17th and early 18th centuries, under the name of “Red Porcelain*’.

No. 2 Chun-Yao or Kuang-Yao.* Name given by Chinese to potters of Province of Kwang-tung. These are hard-fired glazed stonewares, dark grey, red, brown, or blackish usually with thick, variegated or opalescent glazes of grey-blue, green, yellow, or red, but flecked, veined and streaked with other tints. These wares are so like the productions of “Sung" dynasty A.D. 960- 1279 that modern pieces are often taken for the more precious specimens of the earlier period.

The student of Chinese pottery must be alert to the reverence of Chinese for their own antiquities. They have endeavoured to reproduce the famous wares of their ancestors, and often with such skill as to deceive the most expert. Even when the manu- facture of porcelain was at its highest in King-te-dsen. potters in other parts of China made glazed and unglazed wares in

* Pair of Flower Pors in University Museum, Sung Dynast}^ A.D. 960-1269.

89

coloured clays and the Imperial Factory strove to reproduce the most archaic wares that could be found in the Empire.

Porcelain. Broadly speaking pottery in which the body of the ware is vitrified and translucent, also, broadly speaking in which the material is white throughout unless minute quantities of metallic oxides have been definitely added for colour. It is impossible to draw a hard and fast line between porcelain and stoneware, for both many be thoroughly vitrified and translucent, in thin pieces — but generally stonewares are drab, red or brown in the colour of the fired clay, and seldom exhibit the precious quality of opalescence. If the body, of a piece of pottery is not even vitrified, however hard it may be, it is terra cotta, or earthen- ware. The Chinese, accustomed from a very early period to fire their pottery at a high temperature produced vitrified stoneware before any other nation. Also they glazed these stonewares with fusible mineral substances — and from that stage the natural re- finements of methods must necessarily have produced porcelain.

In regions where beds of primary clay were found — the body of the ware would burn whiter than elsewhere — and a mixture of limestone, or marble, with the feldspathic rock would give a glaze of greater ])urity, and brilliance, and one more readily fusible and spreading over the whole piece. One can only guess how many centuries were needed before a ware white enough, and translucent enough to be now classed as porcelain was pro- duced, but the process must have been of gradual evolution. Some Chinese writers ascribe to remote ])eriods the production of wares of this class, but where authentic examples are not to be found, literary evidence alone is not to be accepted without doubt. Au- thorities now believe that something worthy the name of Porcelain was made in dang dynasty A.D. 618-907 (Period of Horses in University Museum*) but we have few pieces earlier than Sung Dynasty A.D. 960-1259 and most of these are properly more fitly de.scribed as Stoneware.

Under Sung Dynasty, China enjoyed great prosperity and all the arts were cultivated. Pottery of distinguished merit was made in many districts, and much of it is classed as ])orcelain because the body is whitish and vitrified — hut far inferiour in

*IIorsc.s, Camels — 'I' wo Officials ami Guardian — splendid artistic urns.

90

finish and translucence to the perfect white porcelain of later times.

Prior to end of 13th century we have no record of any pot- tery with j>ainted decoration — such ornament as used consists entirely of designs incised, or modelled in the clay. The principal decoration is found in varicoloured glazes both of stoneware and porcelain. This early glaze is never clear and white, as in later wares and generally uneven, imperfectly fused, and indicates imperfect technicpie — (they were just learning the use of glaze). Those of this period most highly valued are the “Celedons” with cool bluish or yellowish greens of indescribable depth and softness.

The most famous of these now very rare Sung wares were the Chunchow stonewares, also the black variegated glazed wares of Fu-Kien province known to collectors as Hare’s Fur Cups — and “Partidge Cups”. This Sung Period is that in which Chinese Porcelain became known beyond its native country.

Sulaiman, a Mohammedan traveller in 9th century writes ; ‘‘They have in China a very fine white clay of which they make vases as transparent as glass, water is seen through them.” Its first appearance in the west was about 1188, when Saladin sent a present of forty pieces to Sultan of Damascus. From this time on export developed — particularly in “Celadon” wares of Lung- Chuan. This famous ware the Green Porcelain of the Chinese, probably an imitation of Jade — survives mostly as thick, heavy dishes, bowls and jars, bearing incised or fluted patterns coated with a thick green glaze of remarkably soft tone. Though the body of the ware is white when it is broken, yet any parts not covered by the glaze have a reddish brown colour, due to the un- refined paste, and when in later times the ware was reproduced this reddish brown tint had to be imitated artificially. This ware was highh^ prized in China, Japan, the East Indes and all Mohammedan lands. It was largely used in Persia and specimens have been recovered during last century from East Coast of Africa and as far west as Morocco. Archbishop Warham’s cup at New College, Oxford is the first known specimen to reach England, a celadon bowl of time of Henry VHI.

The Sung Dynasty was overthrown by the Tatars under Kublai Khan, (grandson of Jenghis Khan) who ruled until 1368, when the great native Ming Dynasty was established. During this

91

Tatar or Yuan Dynasty, little progress occurred, but two impor- tant changes took place.

1st The concentration of the industry at King-te-chen completed in early days of Ming Dynasty.

2nd The introduction of painted decoration under a white transparent glaze — the idea, and perhaps the necessary cobalt mineral were brought from Persia.

King-te-chen was already a pottery centre when its factories were rebuilt by Hung-Wu, the founder of Ming Dynasty in 1369, who made this the Imperial works. Porcelain workers were at- tracted thither resulting in abandonment of many other old cen- tres.

The earliest painted Chinese porcelain strongly suggest ideas imported from Persia, in form, substance and ornament, and the technique also, for the ware was fired before glazing. These glazes being similar to those of Egypt and Persia, and quite un- like the Chinese Sung period — the new glazes were fired at a lower heat. Rapid improvement in technical skill followed the con- centration as King-te-Chen.

The varied colours of Persian use, however, would not en- dure the high temperatures used, excepting blue from cobalt, and a wonderful blood red obtained from copper. Blue and white painted porcelains were unknown in 13th century but were fully developed at beginning of 15th centiiry.

During Ming ])eriod was developed the marvelous eggshell porcelain of most delicate ware. Also the well known perforated ware generally called Grain of Rice. The 15th century ])roduc- tion is rated as finest of its class, but the Chinese never abandon an old method, and continue to make blue and white porcelain often of very good quality, yet rarely equalling the older ware.

It is only towards end of 16th century we find first examples of porcelain decorated with colours fired over the glaze. Probably this development arose from use of enamel on metal, which had spread from Byzantium to China, and which Chinese developed with great skill. The very nature of Chinese glazes requiring such high tem|)eratures severely restricted the underglaze to cobalt blue and uncertain cop]^er red. The Western potters, to obtain their rich polychromatic effects had to find other technique and adopted the device of using a finished piece of blue and white and further decoration by very fusible colours painted over the

92

fixed glaze, and then attached to the glaze by refiring at a lower heat equal only to that used by the enaineler on metals.

At first these “On Glaze”, or Enamel Colours were applied as thin washes as in the Ming three colour decorations of green, purple and yellow, developing with Ming five colour schemes in which these same colours are combined with an overglaze red, all being painted over a skeleton ])attern in underglaze blue.

In early 17th century King-te-Chen factories must have pro- duced a very large quantity of porcelain. The requirements of the Court were enormous. One of the stq^ervising censors remon- strating with the Emperor, declared that one year’s demands com- prised over 96,000 pieces. The wares of this j)eriod are inferiour both in material and workmanship to those of immediately pre- ceding and following periods. Quality being sacrificed to quantity, but the export trade was much stimulated. About this time Chinese adopted forms, colours and decorations for these export wares not in accordance with Chinese usage, but pre- sumably more suited to foreign tastes.

Hence the Persian and Syrian styles of painted blue decora- tion of 15th and 16th centuries. Now for the first time came a direct European demand and cargoes were brought to Europe by Portuguese, and later by the Dutch. The production of these wares, however, slowly modified the work of the Chinese them- selves, and paved the way for the new styles of late 17th and early 18th centuries.

The collapse of Ming Dynasty definitely separated the first great period of Chinese porcelain from its second and culminating period. The works at King-te-Chen were destroyed more than once in 17th century. Notwithstanding this however, the potters remained for the reigns of Kang-Hsi,* Yung-Chang and Kien- lung. 1662-1795 covered a century and a half, within which pe- riod the high water mark of artistic production was reached and passed.

During this period the Chinese mind displays both an eager spirit of experiment yet reverencing the production of past ages, and were practicing the new methods of On Glaze decoration.

The “Sang-deBoef” vases, and Hawthorn Ginger Jars came

*Kang-Hsi period 1662-1722. (Specimen parts).

93

to perfection and eggshell wares were made in great perfection. Imperial interest and support were given.

Early in the reign of Charles II, Tea became a fashionable drink and the East India Company set about supplying the appro- priate apparatus for its preparation. A small teapot of unglazed pottery was considered best for the new beverage. Great numbers of such pots made in district of Yi-Shing near Shanghai were acquired by East India Co. agents and forwarded to Europe with shipments of tea.

Many potters flourished in Yi-Shing 1573-1644 making per- fume boxes, vases and other articles as well as the famous teaware. In general, their product varied from a soft pottery to a hard stoneware, usually red but sometimes chocolate brown, buff or drab. It was nearly always unglazed. These were made with great care. Lids and covers always precisely fitted. Proportions and finish were invariably pleasing.

Erom an early Chinese record we learn the ideal Teapot was shallow and small to conserve the flavour of the tea, and to per- mit each guest to have a pot to liimself. The cover should be convex within and the pot have a straight spout to avoid clogging with tea leaves. Although many ])ieces of Chinese Redware were fashioned in fantastic forms, forests, birds and animals, it was the simpler shapes that appealed to the occidental taste. One of the favourite modes of decoration was to engrave the surface with seal characters — this art sometimes took many years to develop required skill. The most popular decorations were j)lum blossom sprays. Much of this ware is later imitation of earlier work.

Red stoneware has been continuously made in China from the Ming Period to the present. (4nly knowledge born of experi- ence can distinguish the antique from the modern. The old shaj)es are still in use. Perhaps the best guide in identifying old pieces are signs of wear and a certain darkening of tbe body due to many years use.

Under the great Ihnperor Kang-Hsi, 1662-1722, the Chinese ex])ort trade vastly ex])anded. The Dutch ICist India Co. founded 1609 brought to Ihiroj)e vast quantities of ])orcelain. European efforts to discover Chinese formula for hard ])aste were not im- mediately successful — the Dutch made some aj)proach. The j)rinciple established in making Red Ware by fusing clay with

94

a natural tiiix, established the direction post for the greater in- vention of true porcelain to follow.

Armorial China for Eiiroi>ean market was manufactured at King-te-chen, and decorated in Canton. The changes in decora- tion replacing the older painting in blue under the glaze, by over- glaze profoundly influenced the style of painting. In the earlier wares the treatment is hold and vigorous and the colours were softened by the melting glaze while painting on an already flred glaze recjuires fine line delicate drawing, which was impossible on the softer surface of other. Naturalism supplants conventional decoration, and elaborate minuteness of finish the broad free- dom of direct brushwork.

In 19th century the growth of European and American manufacture, aided by improved machinery and kilns practically extinguished the export trade of Chinese wares and imperial patronage declined, and the political difficulties of China left less leisure for the cultivation of the arts. King-te-chen was again destroyed in Taiping revolution 1851-61. Since then it has been rebuilt, and is, or was recently, producing Chinese porcelain. Tempted by the high prices now paid in America and Europe for 18th century wares, modern copies of Sang-deBoef vases and Hawthorn Ginger Jars have stimulated undesirable attention.

During 18th century we see gradual disappearance of ancient methods in favour of wares of a beautiful white-body, decorated only with onglaze colours, these principally “famille rose”, and a very large production of inferiour wares in European shapes, and decorated with onglaze painting and gilding to suit the European 18th century taste.

This Armorial China, much of which was attributed to Lowes- toft does not compare favourably with the native wares — the material is seldom of best quality, and the Chinese rendering of European Arms and Crests are inferiour to their own traditional shapes and decoration. Much of the Armorial China, though manufactured at King-te-chen, was decorated in Canton, and a school of pottery decorators was established there for the export trade but also produced some works in pure Chinese taste, partic- ularly some of the Ruby-Backed Plates, dishes and small cups and saucers decorated with cocks, peonies, etc.

Nanking means “The Southern Capital”, is comparatively near Shanghai, and about equidistant between Canton in the

95

south and Peking on the north, is on south bank of Yangtze- Kiang, the chief water way of China and dates from the begin- ning of the Ming dynasty (1368-1644) on the site of a city of various names for more than 2,000 years previously. Seat of the imperial court during reigns of first two “Ming” emperors, later deserted by court for Peking.

In Taiping Rebellion 1853 — captured and the ancient wall destroyed — of which some portions remain about 70 feet high and 30 feet width of base, pierced by 13 gates.

The most conspicuous public building was Porcelain Tower begun in 1413, an octagonal building about 260 feet high, the outer walls cased with bricks of finest white porcelain, and each of the nine stories marked by overhanging eaves of green glazed porcelain tiles. From the eaves hung 152 bells and countless lanterns. Nanking one of the chief literary centres of the Empire, besides being famous for manufacturing industries. Textiles — Nankin and procelains. The most famous porcelains came from the Province of Kiang-Si, the seat of the industry being at King-te-chen. where Imperial works were estab- lished about A.D. 1000. The finest products were sent to Peking for use of the Emperor. At one time it was said that a million workmen were employed and the kilns numbered 600.

Destroyed 1850 in Taiping Rebellion, since somewhat re- built but its product inferiour in both colour and finish to that previously made. At present King-te-chen has 160 furnaces and employs 160,000 workmen.

The common “Rice Bowls” sold throughout China are manu- factured there. Export sales about $2,500,000.

Lowestoft, in Sufifok, England, was an ancient fishing town. During the later 18th century a china factory flourished there, hut this factory was small and has attracted more than merited attention because some writers erroneously attributed to it large quantities of Armorial ware undoubtedly made in China. Recent excavations of site of this factory indicate it was of minor im- ])ortance and princi])ally engaged in ])roducing cheap wares more largely imitating other hhiglish factories. Probably u consider- able (juantity of Chinese ware was smuggled into hmgland through Lowestoft — at least that is one ex])lanation given to the widespread use of the term “Lowestoft” to these wares by deal- ers and collectors.

96

Through the various “India Companies” the importation of Chinese procelains increased largely. With the organization of pottery as a factory industry in the 18th century, improved kilns were developed, and the type now largely used in civilized coun- tries is practically a reverboratory furnace from ten to twenty- two feet in diameter, and of similar height, capable at one firing, of containing as much as the annual output of a mediaeval potter. Recently the development of gas fired kilns has improved both certainty and economy in use.

During the 18th century England developed “Bone China” by adding calcined bones to the other ingredients. This process continues to be largely used today in America, Great Britain, France, Sweden, Denmark and Germany.

The 19th century saw a great growth of output owing to introduction of mechanical methods to supplement what hitherto was almost pure handicraft. Machine printing was introduced, almost extinguishing the artistic spirit. Even the handwork that persisted was affected by the growing dominance of machinery, and decoration became mechanical until the middle of the cen- tury, when a revival of old methods produced some fresh and original work.

In every country, a few were striving to restore to their an- cient craft something of artistic taste and skill and with some results.

Chinese porcelains are fired at so high a temperature that a glaze feldspar softened by lime and silica is found most suit- able. Hard-fired stoneware if rich in silica, may be salt glazed — while for clays that cannot be fired at highest temperatures lead glazes are used. Addition of sand to such clays make salt glazing practicable.

“Lowestoft” is the term frequently used to denote Chinese Export Ware. An attempt is made to substitute “Armorial China” for such pieces but this is quite unsatisfactory, as much of the type of ware bears no armorial designs, but is similar in form and decoration, and in lack of real quality. Chinese porcelains exported prior to 1760 is often of better execution — before the flood of export production. Pieces made subsequently are usu- ally less elaborately decorated. After 1800 greater elaboration is again in evidence, but is usually of a coarse and slap dash type in which the older refinement of ])attern and technique yields to

97

bolder and cruder efiforts more easily achieved, however, occa- sional late items have rare distinction and high excellence. Many persons think all oriental ware is of equal merit, all out of the same pot, but much of the export wares — particularly for the American market was “bargain stufif” — and the buyer received just what he paid for, and no more. These wares were inferiour to those produced a few years before, and to the best products of the same period where cost was not given undue weight.

In any event these less worthy pieces have significance as mementoes of the great days of the “China Trade'’ which got under way from 1784 on to the early 19th century. Probably little of the export ware at this period is as fine in body as that made for oriental consumption, or as that made prior to 1750 for export. If a specimen be held to a strong light many imper- fections may be seen ; and the glazing is usually heavy and coarse. Many of the larger platters brought home by seafaring ancestors in late 1700’s and early 1800’s, though properly prized for asso- ciation, have not too much merit or excellence.

Such gradations are readily explainable. When European traders first began to purchase porcelain in the Orient they ac- quired native wares, as they found them. Mainly underglaze “Blue and White’’ and of prevailingly good quality, thin, quite “clear white”, coni])act in body, but inclined to brittleness. The decoration is usually “heathen designs”, female figures, pagodas, dragons, flowers, etc.

At the outset western traders had no thought of furnishing their own decorative patterns or s|)ecial shaj)es for the Chinese to copy. This did not last long and as early as 1690 attempts to Europeanize oriental porcelains had hegun, as indicated by some early specimens of “Blue and White” Armorial. These are still of an excellent grade of white ])orcelain, with carefully executed l^ainting in blue, and also, as on Chinese wares of same ])eriod, with decoration pencilled on under side of ])late rim.

By 1700 European customers placed orders for plates with monograms or crests. The decorations were but secondary addi- tions to pieces otherwise ])redominantly “(Oriental” in design and (jualily. Among them are howls and ])lates with characteristic Kang-Ilsi (1662-1722) and Yung Cheng deocrative motifs, amid which hhiglish heraldic devices have been ingeniously jdanted. I'he latest of these are about 1750. Meantime commercialization

98

progressed and “made to order” forms adaj)ted to European usage became profital)le.

The great productive era of occideutalized Chinese porcelain followed, and competitive efforts to cheajjen costs began. So far as costs go, this was highly successful, hut the cpiality suffered. Much warped, or otherwise defective ware was j)reserved ex- pressly for the foreign devil chiselers, that otherwise would have been destroyed. Fortunately, however, there were some buyers \vho sought, and paid for, the best wares obtainable.

99

THE WORK OF THE ORIENTAL INSTITUTE IN THE NEAR EAST

An Illustrated Talk by John A. Wilson

Director of the Oriental Institute of the U niversity of Chicago, before the N lunismatic and Antiquarian Society of Philadelphia, on February 25, 1928

An apology is due this society for introducing so youthful a subject as the study of the ancient Near East. It is a paradox that our knowledge of oldest civilized man is fresh news. The Numismatic and Antiquarian Society of Philadelphia was founded in 1857. This was fourteen years before Schliemann began his work at Troy, shifting an emphasis in archeology toward excava- tion. Twenty-five years after your society was founded, Flinders Petrie was beginning to examine the antiquities of Egypt with an attempt at objective analysis. Petrie’s insistence that all ex- cavated material must be studied without regard to intrinsic value or artistic merit inaugurated the era of scientific work.

Scientific method was somewhat slow in capturing the field, and it was not until 1910 that excavations operated under methods which guaranteed control. Now governments which have an anti- ([iiities law insist that expeditions must be manned by professional technicians who know how to record and preserve the material which is removed.

The Oriental institute has the ancient Near bAst as its field of interest. Why should an American institution confine itself to that period and that area? In that part of the world running from h^gyi)t east through Iran, civilized life developed earlier than in any other part of the world. A favorable climate was an important factor in inducing these origins. Similarly, a favor- able climate has jireserved to us more jihysical objects with greater documentation than in any other section of the world.

There we find the beginnings of agricultural life, of govern- ment and law, of literature and science, and all tbe elements of our modern business life. Hundreds of thousands of the Baby- lonian clay tablets are economic: bills of sale, letters of credit, contracts, and promissory notes. A young man working at the Oriental Institute is drawing grajihs, making price charts cover- ing hundreds of years, based on these cuneiform clay tablets from

100

ancient Mesoix)taniia. They are magnificent material to show the heginnings of business life and the credit system.

Fort}' years ago the American historian James Henry Breasted recognized that no one man could cope with the profuse material from the Near East. He dreamt of an institute wherein scholarly specialists would work together to trace the great story of the rise of human civilization. It was not until 1919 that Dr. Breasted succeeded in founding the Oriental Institute with the initial aid of Mr. John D. Rockefeller, Jr. Since that time the Institute has had a dozen field expeditions o])erating in Egypt, Palestine. Syria, Turkey, Iraq, and Iran, and has already pub- lished almost ninety volumes reporting on its researches. These volumes range from technical studies in ancient grammar to gen- eral popular reports on excavations. Together they make up a great story of consecutive record of man’s attempts to lift himself toward a fuller life.

Of our many field experiences in reconstructing this picture I shall here mention only one.

In Palestine the Oriental Institute is excavating the ancient mound of Megiddo, guarding a pass in the Carmel range. From Thutmose HI in 1479 B.C. to General Allenby in 1918 A.D. there have been critical battles at Megiddo. This is Armageddon, the battlefield of the nations, the place where the final conflict between good and evil will take place.

Three years ago that same archeologist who began scientific excavation and who is still excavating in his eighty-fifth year. Sir Flinders Petrie, visited Megiddo, stood on the mound and snififed the air. He said to our staff : “The prevailing breeze comes from the northwest, from the Mediterranean, does it not?" \\T agreed. He said, “You will find the palace of the princes in this northwest corner, because they built where they could catch that cooling breeze from the sea.'’

We sank a deep trench in the northwest corner of the mound and soon found massive stone walls. Developing these walls out. we found that we had a palace area running from about 1500 to 1100 B.C

Some of the small intimate rooms of this palace were floored with crushed limestone. In one small room a corner of this white paving had been replaced by a brown earth patch. Some ancient had here changed the flooring. Wq therefore abandoned the pick

101

and shovel to use knife and brush in excavating that corner. Just a few inches below the surface, we came upon a splendid treasure of gold, the personal things of the Prince of Megiddo about 1350 B.C. It is another document in the history of Armageddon, the battlefield of history. The Prince must have feared invasion and buried his personal things against the invaders. No one who knew that this gold was buried there ever returned to dig it up again.

This is but a sample of what we are receiving from our field expeditions. Brilliant as is the picture at Megiddo, it is no more vivid than the ])icture provided l)y a document written in clay telling of the sale of a slave girl. This great variety of material goes to make up a uniform picture of man’s struggles for the better life.

Out of all these materials, one gets a long-range view on man’s history. One sees six thousand years of ups and downs and continuous struggle as a single story. One sees that man has an unquenchable desire to find the better life for himself and those about him. Man will not rise automatically. There is no evolu- tionary ])rocess which will push him upward to continually better things. He can rise by learning the results of sad experience, and he can rise by lifting himself painfully by his bootstraps. He has an insistent desire to rise, and if this is channelled along lines of mutual understanding, there is no reason why he may not go on to build a saner world.

102

SOME PHASES OE THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION

(Read at a meeting of the Society, November 2, 1938)

P)Y Dr. Henry Pleasants, Jr.

In view of the fact that the Numismatic and Antiquarian Society is meeting here at the home of Mr. Franklin Bache, it has seemed fitting to confine the observations of your speaker to such phases of the American Revolution as were directly concerned with this immediate neighborhood, rather than to attempt to tell a detailed story of the campaigns of 1777-1778 in Chester County. Many of the gentlemen present are probably better informed than your speaker on such well known events as the Battle of Brandy- wine; the Battle of Paoli, (let us, for the sake of military accu- racy. forbear calling it a “Massacre”), and the great encampment at Valley PMrge.

The important matter to be presented for your consideration is the definite evidence that the objective of General Sir William Howe, Commander in Chief of the British Army, was not Phila- delphia so much as the supplies of the American Army at War- wick, Coventry and Yellow Springs in northern Chester County. This fact has apparently missed the attention of most historians except Hinton, who published his History of the United States, in 1849.

In support of this theory, let us review very briefly the move- ments of the British in their march from the Head of Elk into Chester County. A glance at the official map, prepared by Howe’s officers shows that the British moved first in the direction of Wil- mington. They encountered resistance at Iron Hill and Couch’s Bridge; and in the success of these engagements threatened to corner the Americans against the Delaware. Washington, however, extricated his whole army, and moved up the Brandywine to a strong position on the heights near Chadds Ford.

General Howe now led his forces almost directly northward through Hockessin, Delaware, to a point just South of Kennett Square, arriving there on the evening of September 10th, 1777. It is interesting, however, to note that the Hessians, under Knyphausen, had made an extensive foray into the townships of Oxford, New Garden and London Grove prior to joining the main body of the British Army on September 10th. This fact is

103

amply vouched for by the claims for damages made by farmers of this district according to the Act of Assembly of 1782. The exact route of the British may be traced accurately by studying these claims.

At this point in his march, General Howe executed a very dangerous movement. He split his entire army on the very eve of a battle with the enemy who was less than ten miles distant into two sections, one under Lieutenant General Knyphausen to march directly against the Americans at Chadds Ford, and the other under Lord Cornwallis and himself to make a wide flank move- ment of approximately sixteen miles, crossing the west branch of the Brandywine at Trimble’s Ford, and the east branch at Jefferis’ Ford, and attacking the Americans on their right.

Historians have held somewhat divergent views as to the wis- dom of such an unusual movement. Certainly it was at variance with the accepted principles of military tactics of that period ; yet for that very reason it demands careful consideration. General Howe was a leader of proven ability. The danger of utter failure in such a flank movement makes it unlikely to have been attempted in the absence of some transcendently important reasons. What they were concerns us very clearly :

First: A direct attack upon the Americans by the whole Brit- ish Army would have been doubtful of success in view of the ad- vantageous position of Washington or the high ground across the Brandywine.

Second: Even if such a direct attack should be successful from the standpoint of an actual clash of armed forces, the Amer- icans were in a position to fall back along well traveled main roads toward their stores of ammunition, food and clothing in northern Chester County.

Third: If the flank movement were successful, the two sec- tions of the British Army might be able to catch the Americans, figuratively s])eaking, between the two jaws of a pair of ])incers and either ca])ture or destroy their whole army.

Fourth: bwen if the flank movement, combined with the di- rect attack by Knyjdiausen failed to capture or destroy the Amer- ican Army, the retreat of Washington must necessarily l)e towards Chester and Philadelphia, rather than towards the supplies in the north.

WitlK)ut atteni])ting to go into the details of the Battle of

104

Brandywine, it will be seen from the accompanying maps that Howe actually did accomplish what he intended in forcing the American retreat towards Chester. At this ])oint, however, we find considerable evidence to suggest that the American army was either not so very badly beaten in the Battle of Brandywine, or else that Howe was definitely negligent in following up his ap- parent advantage. Certainly, the pursuit of the retreating Ameri- cans to the outskirts of Chester by Major-general Grant, rein- forced by Cornwallis, was a definite error in military judgment. This was later made apparent by the countermarch of Cornwallis beginning on the night of the 15th and 16th of September.

The crux of the whole matter under discussion becomes ap- parent in the events which followed in rapid succession : Washing- ton withdrew his entire army through Chester and Darby to the western shore of the Schuylkill River, which he followed to the ford or fords near the Falls of Schuylkill, then crossed, and re- plenished his ammunition and supplies from the depots near Ger- mantown. If the defense of Philadelphia against the invasion of the British had been his main consideration, it would have been a simple matter for him to have established a strong defense of the city by guarding the fords and fortifying the high ground in the neighborhood of Barren Hill and Chestnut Hill. Instead, he re- recruited his army ; rested a day or two, and made a long forced march westward on September 15th along the Lancaster and Swede’s Ford roads to White Horse Tavern, a distance of twenty- two miles from Philadelphia, arriving at this point about one o’clock on the afternoon of September 16th, in spite of wet weather and heavy roads. To some of us who have studied the situation, this remarkable march fails to indicate the low point of morale in the American army that might have been expected as the result of a conclusive defeat at the hands of the enemy. However that may appear, it is perfectly obvious that Washington had a definite objective in view when he set out from Germantown ; namely, to interpose his entire force between the British and the precious stores at Warwick, Coventry, Hopewell and Reading. A glance at the maps will show that the well-established routes from Wilming- ton and Chester towards the northern section of Chester County bisect the Lancaster and Swede’s Ford roads in the immediate vicinity of the old White Horse Tavern, now known as Plane- brook. A letter from General Anthony Wayne, with the heading

105

“Radnor, 15th mile Stone, Sept. 15, 1777” to General Thomas Mifflin indicates that it was hoped that the Americans could reach this point in time to execute an encircling movement on the British left flank.

The facts seem to suggest that General Howe was none too well satisfied with the results of the Brandywine encounter, else he would have moved immediately one or two regiments north- ward through Turks Head (now West Chester) and crossed the Chester Valley. The pursuit of the Americans by Grant and Corn- wallis to the outskirts of Chester was of no tactical importance whatever. From the evening of September 11th to the morning of September 16th, the main body of the British lay practically idle at Dilworthtown, Chadds Ford and Concord. In this period, the supply base at the Head of Elk was moved to Wilmington, where a base hospital was established on the 14th.

The British line of march took its course almost due north- ward on September 16th, beginning about midnight with the move- ment of Cornwallis’s forces from Ashton Mills and following the general direction of Ridley Creek to its headwaters on the pres- ent property of John J. Sullivan, Esq. at Hershey’s Mill in East Goshen Township, Chester County. The Hessian troops, under Knyphausen moved northward from the hills above Chadds Ford through Turks Head, and followed the Boot Road to the Boot 1 avern. The main body, under General Howe moved northward from Dilworthtown and Concord, probably passing somewhat east of Turks Head, close to Goshen Baptist Church and following the road or roads running almost ])arallel to the routes followed by Kny])hausen and Cornwallis. From this it may be clearly seen that the routes taken by the three sections of the British army converged exactly at the White Blorse Tavern, at which point, ran the Conestoga Pike, the main route from Philadelphia to Yellow Springs, Warwick and other important bases of American sup- ])lies. Had Howe been successful in reaching this highway before the Americans, his course up the Cone.stoga Ih'ke ])ast this house where we are gathered would have been unoj^posed. Wayne’s let- ter, (juoted ])reviously, gives clear indication that the route of the British was likely to be northward, rather than eastward toward Idiiladelpbia, although he exj)resses anxiety lest they “steal a march and pass the fords in the vicinity of the falls unless we Imme- diately march down and give them Battle.” One can read between

106

the lines of his letter that he merely regarded this possible east- ward movement as a contingency that should be anticipated by quick action.

W'ashington reached White Horse about 1 P.M. on September 16th, finding no evidence of the British in the neighborhood. He immediately marched southward by the Boot Road, Ship Road and